Some criticisms that go beyond my computer being a stuffbird -- the capture point system for winning is something that should never be done in dogfights, as it pushes people to focus more on using vehicles exclusively for transport rather than dogfighting. This was an issue in TheBrighterDark's dogfight as well, there's too much pressure to cap rather than fly around and battle others in the sky.
Why not go back to the canyon style dogfight SS had up? As I recall it had little islands scattered around, instead of 2 large, unappealing ones centered between the ships.
And lastly, back in the days when dogfighting in SS servers was the most enjoyable, we had the classic weapons. Kaje's sniper, ephi's shotgun, original gun, RL, etc. They're primitive but work the most in stunt planes, and that's why people used them. Jorgur's dogfight was hands down the most successful, and he used exclusively those older, more entertaining weapons.