broken link - it linked to "javascript:" which isn't valid. <a href="javascript:"> javascript:#, yes. javascript:actualJavaScriptHere, yes. E: you removed this too. good job.
your form points to "<form method=post action>" and dies.
it doesn't do anything.password reset - remove it then E: - you did this
click tracker - fails to connect via ajax to their servers. that might've been just me. E: nope, still doing it. see attached image, port error thing is client sided, ignore it.
sucks because it sucks [ wtf does this even mean, you prove yourself wrong ]
looks fine [ CHECK ]
works fine [ except for what i pointed out CHECK ]
lost respect [ big loving deal. ]
Edit: You said I have a broken link and a link that takes you to a 404? Isn't that the same thing? Don't answer that, because it is. You just wanted to put more bullets on your list so it looked like it was awful.
Broken link - <a href='loliforgeteditupthCIAntreal'>LINK</a>
click this - ah damn it broke. (no 404 or error code, it just flat out doesn't work)
404 link - <a href='thislinkstoarealwebpagethatdo
esntexist.html'>BLAH</a>
click this - ah damn, the webpage doesn't exist (404 reported.)
very different. broken links fail at syntax or direction, 404 links point to a valid resource that does not exist.