Honestly at this point there is nothing keeping this game alive anymore. And while I still believe it holds up to modern day gaming, the playerbase is like 30 people. One major turnoff to new players is that this looks like Roblox, but Roblox is free and BL isn't. I can't imagine that Badspot is really making more than $4 every 5 months at this point.
"Oh but itll be a toxic community"
The current community is already dead.