No single person can just make up a list like this. This kind of stuff would take a while to put together and would need to be based on contribution, fame, etc. You can't just make a "Best Player's List" with a bunch of your friends added because they're your friends.
Even with a fair vote a lot of the younger forum members will most likely vote without really thinking why they should vote for that person. Such that people that have contributed the most may not get recognized as being one of the "best players".