My friends and I are making a game in which you play as a tortilla chip who beats the stuff out of midget veggies and uses their corpses to make salsa.
We're trying to decide on a character style. Number 2 looks like a straight-up NES style character, with flat colors and solid blocks.
Number 1 is essentially the same but with a pillow-shading effect..
Number 3 has a sel-out (selective outline) in which the outline matches the color.
Number 4 has a darker sel-out.
What do you guys think?
Bigger version (a bit blurry):