92
« on: April 11, 2011, 10:50:05 PM »
Background
In 2005 I got a second hand iBook Clamshell. Later that year a second hand Acer Travelmate. In 2006 I got a brand new Compaq Presario M2000. On the last day of 2007 (New Years Eve 2008) I got an Intel MacBook. In 2009 I purchased an EeePC 701 notebook, and a second hand iMac G3 Strawberry. In 2011 I purchased a Compaq Presario CQ62-357TX. Throughout my life I have been deeply involved in using both Mac and PC products, and enjoying them equally. I have developed an opinion on both, and I feel I have been able to get really thorough usage from both, with an unbiased perspective.
If you are too much of a child to read this, accept or disagree with it, and respond to it in a civilized way, you will only make yourself look stupid.
Microsoft and the PC
Microsoft's products have a very executive and practical feel. You never get Microsoft making softwaer that is designed to be really dumbed down for the enduser as Apple does. Some think this is good, and some bad. Personally I prefer it when the developer doesn't assume I'm an idiot.
When I used XP I enjoyed it mostly. In hindsight the GUI was gross and cartoonish and I'd never go there again, but at the time it was cool. Windows Movie Maker gave me many memories of making stupid low-framerate cartoons using paint, so I thank you MS.
Gaming on the PC has always been a solid experience. From XP to 7, gaming is an assured asset assuming you have the hardware to boot.
Viruses on Windows aren't as common as some like to flog, but they are definitely something people should take seriously. I hate antivirus products, I stopped using them for a year, but I've recently found peace with the un-intrusive Avast.
The XP interface was okay. I don't love it, I never did, but everything worked nicely and was organized. I've had a few driver problems with my old PCs in the past, but that was some time a go.
My recent laptop is great. Windows 7 is by far the most superior OS in the Windows series I feel. Its beautiful interface is great. Microsoft didn't stoop to ripping off the Apple dock, but instead removed folders and programs leaving a long rectangle button in the taskbar and replaced them with square icons that act almost as a mini-dock. Actually, I prefer it over Apples dock because I love my start menu on the side.
Windows 7 has nice customization options for the window, like changing the color. Hey, its basic, but its more than Apple lets you do at this stage.
Windows is easily customizable. You can add whatever you want easily, pull apart the GUI with a massive bank of themes, and just get down and dirty with your system. With MacOS, its not that easy. There must be one or two programs that let you change the theme for MacOS, and that is sad.
PCs are generally better for your budget. You can get some really good quality hardware for a good price. And when you buy a PC, you have far more range when it comes to design of the case.
Bluescreens... a thing of the past. Hey, I've had a bluescreen once or twice this year but its nothing like it used to be.
Apple and the Mac
Apple is very self contained. They design really superior looking, beautiful machines. If you don't mind the fact every other Mac user has a computer that looks the same, there is no problem. The build quality is always perfect, and you will always be assured you'll get the best performance for your operating system when you get a Mac, and Apple makes their software for their hardware. Its a match made in heaven, un-poisoned by an overflowing range of varying quality hardware like you get in the PC world.
Apple's MacOS is just as beautiful as the hardware. The price for a Mac is far too much for most people when you can compare what the same amount will get you for a PC, but you aren't wasting your money when you get a Mac. You get the customer service, the perfectly crafted OS, the build quality, the brand, and the overall experience of having a Mac. But for some, that is not good enough when a PC is just as much of a contender. For others, the PC doesn't even stand up to a Mac. I think that all comes down to taste and brand loyalty, really.
MacOS Tiger was a bit ugly. MacOS Leopard far nicer. The range of software for MacOS is great, the Steam platform is a start for gaming, and the old rumour of "you can't right click with MacOS" has and still is an ignorant lie spewed by people who never used one long enough to figure out the basics.
Apple has very quality products. But they date quickly, and they cost a lot. You always feel locked down by Apple, and their bundled software is slowly digressing to an audience like your grandmother who needs a dumbed down interface and few things cluttering the interface. I don't like that, because Apple is slowly taking away features that way. iMovie 09' and beyond makes generic stuffty movies, I still use iMovie 6.
Apple does make some things easier, granted. No driver woes, less to worry about when it comes to viruses, and a really fast no fuss desktop space.
Customization is less of an ability. You certainly feel the restrictions of MacOS, if you are a techie that doesn't want to be a slave to Apple's design philosophy-- even though their design is superb.
Apple has some really cool software too. Garageband is fantastic. The iWork suit is superb. Very great tools indeed.
Verdict
The PC is a good choice if you know what hardware is good, and what is not. Assuming you find a quality make, a computer with an OS like Windows 7 pre-installed is a better way to go for reliable gaming, or for people who are likely to need space for customization. If you don't mind getting your hands dirty with the system, the Windows platform is great. Furthermore, you have far more ability to tweak the hardware itself than with a Mac. Price wise you are going to get more bang for your buck, as far as the practical side of things goes.
The Mac is a great choice if you want a really sleek computer, guaranteed to work well and be no fuss. If you just want a simple computer to use, or if you are an Apple enthusiast or simply like the Apple philosophy, you'll be doing just fine with Mac products-- assuming money is less of an obstacle. Professional work and gaming is capable on the Mac now, Mac computers are no longer just for graphic designs and schools. You aren't missing out on much assuming you like the OS and hardware how it is and don't mind playing catchup with the PC world when it comes to computer gaming.
Anyone else agree? :I