I READ THE OP
AND IT LOOKS LIKE stuff.
wah wah i can't give constructive critiques wah wah
As for the item itself, it does give what you'd expect, kinda, a black scythe, if you're like twisting it in some form. However, don't feel too afraid to get edgier or rounder with your shapes. The tip of the blade looks a bit more flat like a hoe or a pickaxe, from the angle given. Try to give the stem or whatever a shape different than a rectangle, and make it longer (so it doesn't get confused with other tools). The tip of the steel/wood stem thingie that goes through the blade seems to merge with the blade itself. Maybe shorten that part on the blade. In all it's a mash-up that leaves much to be desired for a scythe, maybe toss in extra shapes, whatever makes it look more like a scythe. If you're not willing to put out however I don't think modeling is your thing, taking into account what you said was the time you took to make it.
