Author Topic: I need you guys to rate a story of mine  (Read 762 times)

So, I started work on a project, and I'm in pre-pre-pre-writing. That means I just started, so I need you guys to rate what I have so far and tell me how I can improve.

PROLOGUE
His wand glimmered in the night sky, shining a tremendous glow of blood red. The powers he possessed were beyond arcane, his mastery of sorcery and swordplay apt in his situation.
“Face me, Hagen.”
He held his sheath tight, expecting an attack at any point in time.
“Face me, coward!”
Hagen reached for his radio, this boy was beyond his strength, and if he wanted to take him out, he’d need assistance.
“Katy, you there?”
The static of the radio filled the room.
“Radio help won’t get you anywhere.”
The boy lifted his wand, and with a brief chant, the room was abundant with fire.
“I told you, face me.”
Hagen shivered, his fate was inevitable; he would either be impaled by the boy’s sword, or burned by the flames. But as he stood prone, the ground shook, and the desk he was hiding behind exploded.
“There you are, rusty son of a bitch.”
The boy unraveled his sword, and was about to strike, when suddenly Katy appeared out of nowhere, and a booming noise filled the room. The boy was now bleeding out of his chest, still standing and apparently alive as ever. He looked more fierce than he had before, but instead of attacking Hagen, he turned straight to Katy. She held up her gun, pointing it at the boy.
“You don’t know the mistake you’re making.” Katy exclaimed.
The boy kneeled, losing his strength. Katy held her hands up and a green light faded above her. The boy was now crying, his sadness at most was a cough and a hand held up. Katy felt no sympathy for him whatsoever, she walked over to him and kicked him off of his knees. He gave out a soft bundle of tears, right as Katy shot him dead.

So, I need constructive criticism. This is a long term project for me, I have no extreme plans for it so far, but I do feel opinions are necessary.


in my opinion there was a lot of unnecessary dialog where there could have been a more detailed narrative.
for example, i'm not really getting a good image of what the room was, etc. try to go over (re-write) this a few times and it will improve a lot.

in my opinion there was a lot of unnecessary dialog where there could have been a more detailed narrative.
for example, i'm not really getting a good image of what the room was, etc. try to go over (re-write) this a few times and it will improve a lot.
I was thinking about this too, thank you.

I was thinking about this too, thank you.
also one last thing is that if this is not a short story, it's progressing way too fast.

I'm a writer, so please excuse me if I'm very harsh. Know it's because I want to help you become a better writer in the long-run.


His wand glimmered in the night sky, shining a tremendous glow of blood red. The powers he possessed were beyond arcane, his mastery of sorcery and swordplay apt in his situation.
The intro was...boring. It felt really generic. Instead of setting the atmosphere, you tried to throw us directly into the action; unfortunately, that doesn't give the audience a good impression.

I always start written stories by describing the location in the most detail with the least amount of words. It takes a lot of practice, but you should try it; I want you to describe the room you're in, and do it in under a 10 word sentence. The better you get, the more that sentence will be able to actually let the audience emulate the feeling of the environment around them.

Example: "Shivering cold winds roared through the light-less, lifeless forest."

Also, I feel the use of "arcane" is incorrect to a degree; there's a word that's probably more fitting. Arcane means that it's understood by few. "Beyond arcane" just bugs me. I'd also refrain from using "apt in this situation", and considering using something like "would become crucial within moments". It creates a bit of tension as the reader wonders why he might need those skills.

“Face me, Hagen.”
On the first line, I always love to give a description of the character's voice. It gives the audience a great idea of what the character is like through their verbal presentation, if you understand what I mean. Something like 'Snarling like a wild hog, his heavy words edged their way out, "Face me, Hagen."' might work better for you, although personally I think you should rewrite it to something that sounds a lot better and fits the character.

He held his sheath tight, expecting an attack at any point in time.
“Face me, coward!”
Better. The abrupt absence of the voice description works, since we can already establish what he sounds like, so we can begin to imagine how he emotionally feels and thus how he would say this line.

You might want to throw in a little bit of description of the character, followed by "He held his sheath tight...". I would even describe the sheath a bit too. You need to paint the scene for the audience, because otherwise they will unfortunately switch off.

Hagen reached for his radio, this boy was beyond his strength, and if he wanted to take him out, he’d need assistance.
I do love that you were grammatically correct with the commas, but in longer sentences they can cause readers to switch off as they become distracting, and it sounds like the narrator is the kid from Malcolm in the Middle. Either try break your sentences up a bit more, or reword it so there's less pausing/commas.

The "this boy was beyond his strength" was very awkward. I would have used a full stop and started that as a new sentence. I'd also consider changing the word "boy" to be more descriptive. You may even throw in a line saying how Hagen really doesn't want to call for assistance, but he has no choice.

The more you throw in character personality descriptions (while keeping them subtle), the better. We learn more about the character, and we can relate better to them. Remember to make sure your characters are 3D and complex.

“Katy, you there?”
The static of the radio filled the room.
We need more atmosphere here. Draw it out. Make the audience get really freaked out by how tense and scary the situation is. What does the static feel like?

“Radio help won’t get you anywhere.”
Not scary enough. Fill it with a bit of pathos (emotions). You should make the audience afraid of this guy. His dialogue should feel like insects crawling up my skin.

If this guy is evil, make him a loving nightmare. There's different types of evil; choose one, and then make him a total badass.

The boy lifted his wand, and with a brief chant, the room was abundant with fire.
More description, please. Maybe add a few lines from the chant? Also, when the room goes on fire, MAKE IT BURN. You need to make this exciting. There needs to be energy in the writing.

"Within an instant, light burst into the room, followed by the all too well known smell...the heat rose and destruction ravaged. The room began to burn..."

It's a stuffty example, but hopefully you get the point; make your writing expressive of the state of the story. Also, I didn't really do it, but when there's more energy, you should rely less on commas and try to make the writing feel "fast-paced".


“I told you, face me.”
I'd argue that you could separate this into two sentences. It would feel more dramatic like that.

Hagen shivered, his fate was inevitable; he would either be impaled by the boy’s sword, or burned by the flames. But as he stood prone, the ground shook, and the desk he was hiding behind exploded.
Aside from expansion on the detail, this is not bad. Let's feel that explosion. Let's feel Helgan's fear of death. I should have my heart racing at this point.


“There you are, rusty son of a bitch.”
The boy unraveled his sword, and was about to strike, when suddenly Katy appeared out of nowhere, and a booming noise filled the room.
I'm guessing the dialogue is Katy? The next line should be specifically about Katy, so we link the action with her. That "unravelled his sword" bit should be before Katy arrives. It would also be more dramatic if he's JUST about to swing the sword for the final blow, when Katy appears and saves the day.

The boy was now bleeding out of his chest, still standing and apparently alive as ever. He looked more fierce than he had before, but instead of attacking Hagen, he turned straight to Katy. She held up her gun, pointing it at the boy.
More description. Maybe even try and reveal a bit of the character's motivations at this point, showing that the boy has decided to forgo his original motivation to instead deal with the near, more dangerous threat.

“You don’t know the mistake you’re making.” Katy exclaimed.
All parts of this were very generic. You should keep her line to about 4 or less words, and then allow your description to carry the reader's imagination.

Don't use "exclaimed". There are fair better ways to show a character has said something with gusto.

The boy kneeled, losing his strength. Katy held her hands up and a green light faded above her. The boy was now crying, his sadness at most was a cough and a hand held up. Katy felt no sympathy for him whatsoever, she walked over to him and kicked him off of his knees. He gave out a soft bundle of tears, right as Katy shot him dead.
For the final time, more description. Also, SHOW DON'T TELL. Do not tell us that Katy feels no sympathy. Show us that Katy doesn't care through her next few actions. Use dialogue if you really must, but avoid exposition. I did like ending on the shot fired; it's fairly dramatic to end abruptly.

---

As far as the overarching story, I do have one problem: What does it tell us?

Not much.

A Prologue should contain a very important piece of information about the setting, the characters or the story's problem (the conflict the characters have to resolve) that the audience will need to try and decode over the course of the story. A good prologue has a hidden piece of information that will only become useful to the audience (and the main character) in the 3rd Act.

Meaningless action like this doesn't really establish much, except for some general character personality traits which I assume will be learnt through the main story anyway. I feel you should change the prologue so that it contains a very important piece of information, and so that it also gives us a very brief overview of the world we're in. It felt like you rushed us into this environment, without telling me where the characters are. I was actually very confused when I found out he was in some kind of room; I thought they were in a forest at first.

---

Overall, absolutely not the worst piece I've looked at, but you do have plenty of places to improve, which is half the fun. That said, you did pretty good, OP :) Keep working on it; I think you have a talent for writing, and you just need some refinement.

Quote
A blood red glow filled the night, as the boy's wand glimmered in his hand. Despite his youth, he possessed powers that were beyond the arcane, skills in the lineage of sorcery and swordplay that were nearly unmatched throughout the realm. His midnight travels were commonplace for him, preferring the cold darkness of the stars over the warm rays of the sun. Tonight was no different, until he stumbled upon a familiar cabin, tucked in the deepest part of the forest. He swept past the fire-lit windows, rising onto the porch with barely a sound. A deafening blast from his wand jolts the thick wooden door off its hinges, revealing the familiar inhabitant.

The boy mutters, "Face me, Hagen." Holding his sheath tight, he withdraws his sword to position it in line with the bearded man's face. "Face me, coward!", yells the boy, more agitated as his first commands were unanswered. The man, seated in-front of his hearth, smoothly stands up, turning to face his visitor. He reaches for the flask he was sipping from before he was rudely interrupted, and with a sudden twist to open the top, he slams it on the ground beneath his feet. The illusory smoke that fills the room shocks the boy, who attempts to clear the room with his many anti-hexes, only able to clear it enough to see the man is gone.

Hagen's calls for help over his HAM radio, stashed away in his cabin's basement are met with only static, worrying no one is there to hear him, he begins to panic. With the boy's unimaginable strength, Hagen admits to himself that his destined end might be upon him, as without reinforcements he is no match for this adversary.

The trapdoor from the room above blasts open in a similiar fashion to the front door, and with its ejection, the room fills with hot, blue flames. Hagen, now surrounded by fire, grabs his only weapon, a rusty sledgehammer probably once used on the property for labor, and retreats behind a central pillar of the basement. "I told you, face me." the boy snarls as he descends down into the inferno. With a quick blast from his wand, the pillar is engulfed in flames, which forces Hagen out of hiding. Shivering with fear, he drops to his knees, not muttering a word and intensely staring at his foe. "There you are..." a sighing statements slips from the boys mouth, as he begins to draw back the sword in preparation to strike.

A loud gunshot fills the silence, as the boy twirls around to face a new intruder. Katy, Hagen's partner, stands at the base of the ladder with a gun pointed directly at the boy. Blood begins pouring from a wound near the young master's heart, but his physical demeanor seems unchanged, almost as if the lethal shot had no effect on him. He charges at Katy, who successively fires shot after shot to no avail. Just as he seems ready to strike at the now cowering woman in the corner of the blue-lit room, Hagen's swing makes contact with a heavy strike to the boy's head. Stopped in his tracks, he falls to his knees, dissolving into ash right before the duo's eyes. The flames extinguish, and only the sound of his sword and wand clattering to the stone floor fill the air.
I like where you're going with it, but you really need to be more descriptive when it matters, aka not during the action, and you need to work out some of the awkward phrasing. You've got a bunch of good descriptions, some really don't work with whatever your trying to describe.

I didn't type mine out to say that you should write like me, and I'm especially not saying that I'm that good of a writer that you should completely listen to, but I hope I gave you an idea of what at least I'd like to read. Also, a disclaimer, it's 2:47 AM and I can only check my grammar and general syntax so much at this point, so read what I meant to say, not what I might've actually wrote.

Edit:
-snip-
Listen to this man.
« Last Edit: January 01, 2015, 04:53:17 AM by Oasis »

Thanks, McJob.

I tried to combine 3 genres, Dark Fantasy, Arcanepunk Fantasy and semi-thriller.



i didnt even get the tiniest bit aroused

i didnt even get the tiniest bit aroused
yeah i'm just practicing my universal skills like writing, drawing and reading.

anyway, McJob, I've been thinking heavily about what you said.

Would this be a good introduction for a story?

I'm not actually going to incorporate this, I just want to make sure I get what you're saying.

PROLOGUE:
Outran were the leaves, tired as their troubles lead them from the trees who held their weight to the ground that shined at the peak of dawn. Liam loved the slow breeze of the wind against his face, the quiet, gentle touch of the flowers against his shin. He was a human, after all, a deviant of nature, as far as the world was concerned. He sped across the forest, happy that he was in his place. Forever. Or at least that’s what he thought.

11/10 because of the appealing word "Prologue" at the beginning