Author Topic: BLF Test-reads McZealot's Book  (Read 743 times)

« Last Edit: November 16, 2016, 08:43:57 PM by McZealot »

Are you going put the BLF in the credits?

the writing is a little awkward in some places, but it is overall quite intriguing.

Are you going put the BLF in the credits?
If you watch a movie, do you get put in the credits for watching it?

Quote from: Gelred: First Contact
The monitor was shattered, but still functional.
Wait, what?
Shattered monitor = screen is completely destroyed and there's a hole through it
How could it still be functional?
Is this a reference to the title or something?

Wait, what?
Shattered monitor = screen is completely destroyed and there's a hole through it
How could it still be functional?
Is this a reference to the title or something?
shattered does not mean destroyed

shattered does not mean destroyed
maybe a better word is cracked

ok problem number 1 is the shortness of every chapter
they're ridiculous. it's like you're confusing chapters with pages

second, this bit in the first chapter
"He couldn't forget."
is way too dramatic for opening a door

this might just be me but sentences that even just barely rhyme in an otherwise non-rhyming piece of literature really put me off
"He entered the appropriate commands. It was difficult to type with shaking hands."

lastly, please god, don't use onedrive to show us this. plain text will work perfectly fine

thanks for the advice!

i don't understand what you mean by "he couldn't forget" being too dramatic. it was (paraphrasing) "He entered the combination on the keypad. Inbrass had been chanting it in his head--he couldn't forget." so it was clearly saying "he couldnt forget the combination"

yeah it is very short. they are just excerpts and if finished there would be hundreds. The nice thing is that it means I can write one a day easily, but I agree that they are just a little bit too short. I might try adding a paragraph or so to each one. They do get longer as it goes, but I feel extremely short dramatic chapters are the best way to engage someone just checking something out.

as I said here:
the chapters are merely excerpts, just 2-6 paragraphs long
While I enjoy the extremely short style at the start, I'd like to systematically increase the length of each chapter. It not only feels like you are developing the stories and characters but also gives space to add in little details people won't care about early on.


I totally agree with the rhyming sentences bit. I hadn't noticed that before but when people rhyme in their posts I find it really distracting. Will reword.

Not moving it from OneDrive. It's written in Microsoft Word so using OneDrive keeps the formatting, text size, and text effects. Some bits are really awkward without italics. It's also very easy to just drag and drop the file into OneDrive, and I can update it without changing the link.

maybe a better word is cracked
Ehhhh... I think shattered works alright. It clearly collided with someone and had cracks all over it. "Cracked" really minimizes the impact. While in most cases I would agree that you assume "shattered" also means "dysfunctional" if you immediately assess that it is functional it does not count.

the writing is a little awkward in some places, but it is overall quite intriguing.
Yeah, I agree. Second chapter is the least polished IMO. I would appreciate it if you identified awkward sentences for me.

its really more like a novella or a really long short story
Novel is not the write word to describe it, but I don't think Novella is either. It's a collection of related stories, for lack of a better phrase.
« Last Edit: August 28, 2015, 08:06:26 PM by McZealot »

its really more like a novella or a really long short story

yeah so I think I know what I'm going to do. Instead of calling each little excerpt a "Chapter" I'm going to call them excerpts (or something) and each chapter will be made of of like a dozen of them. It would be a lot easier to manage.

also: 3 second drafts have been added.

WHOOP BOOP ALL OF CHAPTER 1 COMBINED SO YOU DONT HAVE TO OPEN A DOZEN DIFFERENT DOCUMENTS

CHAPTER 2 IS BEING REFINED