Blockland Forums > Gallery
AoB Application: The Micro Mansion
Wehrmacht:
it isn't original
also, no, almost perfect is a definite no
mansions are constantly done
where did i imply i pulled a low rating out of my ass
i gave an accurate rating based on how well this could be done
10/10 is a completely perfect build, and i would not ever hand that out like free candy
i would possibly give bones titanic that rating
--- Quote from: Tom on May 12, 2011, 06:23:14 PM ---
If you seriously think this build deserves less than a 7, leave your elitism at the door.
--- End quote ---
i have not shown any elitism, try using the correct vocabulary next time
Tom:
--- Quote from: Wehrmacht on May 12, 2011, 08:29:04 PM ---it isn't original
also, no, almost perfect is a definite no
mansions are constantly done
--- End quote ---
Yes, but this is origonial because it's a new take on mansions. Most mansions are done in the same classical style.
--- Quote from: Wehrmacht on May 12, 2011, 08:29:04 PM ---where did i imply i pulled a low rating out of my ass
i gave an accurate rating based on how well this could be done
--- End quote ---
One line saying it lacks floors and looks "weird" does not justify a rating. And if you knew how well this could be done, you would actually suggest ways of improving it. And honestly it seems like you just basing your rating off how many stripped walls tiled floors their are.
--- Quote from: Wehrmacht on May 12, 2011, 08:29:04 PM ---10/10 is a completely perfect build, and i would not ever hand that out like free candy
--- End quote ---
Ok I might have been a little generous, but 5/10 is an average build. This is at least better than average, especially considering what I've been seeing in-game lately.
Ok I'm done turing this into a drama topic, but people need to be better at rating. You have to consider the overall look, you can't just start taking points off for every little error you see.
Wehrmacht:
why would i need to suggest ways to improve the mansion to show my knowledge on these
my rating is based on the overall quality of the build, which is not above-average
this is average considering what i've been seeing in-game.
AJCW:
You guys are taking this too seriously.
Trifax:
--- Quote from: Tom on May 12, 2011, 06:23:14 PM ---Unlike some people here, I don't just pull low ratings out of my ass. Ia consider the originality of the design, how the details reflect the style and how the builds overall executed. This build deserves a 9 or 10 because it's almost perfect. This build is original because I've never seen something with this style before. I really love the simplicity of it too. The details reflect the style really well. It perfectly fits the style description the OP provided. Sure, the walls may be bland but that's how most stucco houses are. The exuction of this build is good, besides a few minor hiccups.
If you seriously think this build deserves less than a 7, leave your elitism at the door.
--- End quote ---
Don't get your panties in a bunch, he just meant there's always room for improvement. Even in the best of builds. Of course it's all opinion, but you can't jump on our backs because we're not calling the build perfect (which is what a 10/10 means) and so far I've never seen a "perfect" build, and I've seen some great builds. Point being there's always room for improvement.