"The Legend of Carl" Thread is stupid

[SeventhSandwich]

Except you don't just say "I hate x because it's stupid". That's pretty much the equivalent of saying "I hate x because I hate x". Explain why you think it's stupid.

Immaturity and generally awful art. I think the thread was made poorly. There you go. Now let us discuss.

[Ad Bot]

[skill4life]

[Tingalz]

There is absolutely no story, the humor consists almost entirely of poop jokes, and in all it is just very immature.

[Qwepir]

It just looks to me like a newbie trying to make his first forum adventure. Sure the art's bad and the plot's aimless and immature, but that just goes to show that the person who's making it is just a kid.

Also, I fail to see why you would go to drama to provide criticism for a forum game. Drama is where you go to open the floor to stuffslinging and arguments, not a discussion of opinions. Here's a thought. Why don't you actually post in the thread giving some advice and constructive criticism instead of opening a new drama thread to complain?

[SeventhSandwich]

Also, I fail to see why you would go to drama to provide criticism for a forum game. Drama is where you go to open the floor to stuffslinging and arguments, not a discussion of opinions. Here's a thought. Why don't you actually post in the thread giving some advice and constructive criticism instead of opening a new drama thread to complain?

Is qwepir really complaining that my thread isn't bad enough...?

[Qwepir]

No, I'm saying you shouldn't have made it in the first place.

[SeventhSandwich]

No, I'm saying you shouldn't have made it in the first place.

...Because it's not bad enough?

[Qwepir]

Because drama is not the place to go to to complain about one small self-contained thread. If he was posting his awful art elsewhere, or he made multiple equally bad threads, that's one thing. This is just a kid making stuff he thinks is funny, and it looks like some people are contributing and having fun so just step off and let them do their thing. This is just being petty.

[SeventhSandwich]

Because drama is not the place to go to to complain about one small self-contained thread. If he was posting his awful art elsewhere, or he made multiple equally bad threads, that's one thing. This is just a kid making stuff he thinks is funny, and it looks like some people are contributing and having fun so just step off and let them do their thing. This is just being petty.

For one, the drama board right on the index says, "Internet drama and interpersonal problems". This is on the internet, consider it a problem. There's the sole exception that the thread has to be about blockland. It is because it's about the forums.

Your single argument despite the questionable placement of this thread, is that, "It's awful art, it's unfunny, it's bad. He thinks it's funny and some people are contributing. So stop complaining". You've got to admit that this is riddled with fallacies, because of the fact that just because people are contributing, doesn't make the quality of the thread any less awful.

I don't get your argument.

[Qwepir]

It's awful but nobody's forcing you to look at it. Quit making mountains out of molehills, that thread isn't a problem. This thread is just as dumb as making a drama topic about a topic in gallery because you think the build is ugly and the poster is immature. Instead of hiding out here in the drama section, you should have voiced your complaints to the OP of the thread, much like Ike did.

[SeventhSandwich]

It's awful but nobody's forcing you to look at it. Quit making mountains out of molehills, that thread isn't a problem. This thread is just as dumb as making a drama topic about a topic in gallery because you think the build is ugly and the poster is immature.

Nice logic

1. "It's bad, but you're overreacting".

2. That brown townogy is flawed.

[chrisbot6]

Can I just ask what your goal is by starting this thread?

Because if it was to see if others opinions were the same as yours, i'm afriad mine isn't. They're just having fun, and nobody made you look at their thread. Also, as far as I can tell, it breaks none of the forum rules.

[Qwepir]

Nice logic

1. "It's bad, but you're overreacting".

2. That brown townogy is flawed.

1. You are. This did not need a thread.
2. No it isn't. You're making a drama thread to whine about the quality of the art in a creativity thread. That's as batstuff stupid as making a drama thread to whine about the quality of a build in the gallery.

[Jairo]

imo.
This is pointless.

[Jairo]

-snip-
imo.
This is pointless.

Let me rephrase that: This thread is leading into a huge argument about art in a building community amongst other things. Just leave the kid alone for Christ's sake.