Additionally, considering that not only were we the first, but also the most successful of all servers in the Boss Battles genre, I don't see a big issue with using a name that at least has some air of authenticity to it. It's not like anyone is going to get even close to having as well-made a server as ours.
Don't think too highly of yourselves now. I know quite a few people who could easily match it. It's rude to say that
nobody will even be able to come close.
I don't see what's wrong with servers sponsoring each other.
I don't really see a need to sponsor people, it's not like these servers are obscure or anything. What exactly is the purpose of sponsoring each-other? Are they paying you in exchange for having a billboard on your server or something? It seems rather silly.
Admin applications and a judging panel have helped keep our admins to the highest standards. This is of course just an opinion on both our behalves, but I have not seen it go wrong for us.
I can pick admins of the "highest standards" without having them fill out some form about why they are so qualified to be accepted into your administration guild. Over time it seems to have become more and more pretentious. This is one server, not a global moderator position. Why do you feel the need to take your administration system to the extreme? It's a massive ego-jerk, "Why should we accept you" "You need to prove yourself". Filling out an application in a proper 'format', writing a couple paragraphs describing your experience, gathering recommendations from 'distinguished' blockland hosts. This is what I mean by blockland servers taking themselves too seriously.
I'd need to know more about what you dislike about donation tiers to really discuss that at all with you.
I also don't see what's wrong with running the server like a business. For the record, it is not a business; our goal isn't to make any money. But I feel running it like such helps keep things less chaotic.
This isn't a damn kickstarter project. You don't need 8 damn tiers for donations. "an email address at pecon.us", seriously? this goes back to my point of taking yourselves too seriously. You can say that acting 'professional' helps keep things organized. then it's fine, but 8 donation tiers, sponsoring, and offering people subdomains/emails provide no organizational benefit. You say it helps "keep things less chaotic", but it seems counter intuitive. If you want to keep things "less chaotic", remove the superfluous stuff.