Let's clarify a few things.
I finally cracked him and he just spilled out the information he had, but I'm still skeptical.
I did not crack lol. I freely gave the info because the issue has been resolved to my satisfaction. The reason I would not give any info at first was because I was still investigating and wanted to make sure that the rumor was false and that the full keys were not really taken. My server
was hacked and exploited with a directory traversal attack according to my source (which has since been fixed) and they got the key.dat files, but they were unable to get the full keys from them due to being unable to break the encryption completely, only what they showed in the photo posted. He told me the only copy of the partial keys have been deleted as well. I have never kept any keys on the server, the only place a key ever resides on my server is in the key.dat and it has always been that way.
Cowboy6 apparentally has knowledge that Man Of Reason is in on this, along with a few other people including possibly Computermix, Ipquarx, and CCa.
The guy signed the email "mor.", I have no way of knowing if it's really him. You may draw your own conclusions from all of this, but as far as I will ever be able to know, the keys are safe and no one else has them.