Off Topic > Off Topic
Who killed Mr. Boddy in the study and with what?: the great debate topic™®
IkeTheGeneric:
gay people don't have a soul, resonte
TheABELBOTO:
It's very likely they either A. were given the original recordings and they modified it to sound better, or B. They re-recorded the line incorrectly but sticked with it.
Either way it's handicapped and anyone who says it's proof of parallel universes are mental.
Ipquarx:
--- Quote from: Master Matthew² on January 12, 2017, 10:59:16 PM ---First where is your evidence it has been edited?
The claim requires evidence, or evidence based suspicion at least.
So no, the burden of proof doesn't rest of me here, as you are the one making the claim it is fake.
--- End quote ---
I don't think you understand how burden of proof works. Let me explain:
You're the one trying to make a claim here: That the "mandella effect" is true, that some sort of parallel universe or some sort of similar timeline forgetery has occured. That means that burden of proof on this claim is on you. The "evidence" that you've provided so far is: "This christmas ornament has different audio from the movie." But that's not what you're actually saying. Because so what if it doesn't have the same audio, that proves nothing. It could be, and indeed would be entirely reasonable for it to be edited. What you're actually claiming is that "This christmas ornament does have the same audio as the movie, and is hence unedited. It seems incorrect because we're in a different timeline that had a different movie." Your claim rests upon the fact that the audio is unedited audio from the movie, and since that's part of the claim you're making, burden of proof is on you. I've told you why it's entirely reasonable for them to edit the clip, just pulling out a "Luke" from one of Darth's other voice lines or requesting it from the movie studio. This is called reasonable doubt. You have to do away with that reasonable doubt in order to "prove" your claim.
The Resonte!:
--- Quote from: IkeTheGeneric on January 12, 2017, 11:07:51 PM ---gay people don't have a soul, resonte
--- End quote ---
you'll have to get someone to sell their soul to you then first >:(
IkeTheGeneric:
here's my argument to this:
i don't have enough evidence to dispute matthew's claims; i do not know enough about alternate dimensions to dispute him. HOWEVER...take into account matthew's history of poor judgemental and reasoning skills... it's likelier that matthew is more susceptible to fall for some bullstuff than it is that he shifted between dimensions somewhere in the past 10 years. occam's razor dictates that is true until proven otherwise