All I can think of is Jim Carey's website, but he ain't a food.
Neopets?
yepit was called something like wacky mart and no longer existsi played it too and have been searching for it for a while to no avail
the part i remember was in a mart youre probably right
DAS WAS loving RIGHT[im g]http://i.imgur.com/8lghhlo.png[/img]I WENT ON WAYBACK MACHINE AND WHILE IT DOESNT WORK, I REMEMBER THIS loving MENUTHIS HAS BeEN IN THE BACK OF MY MIND SINCE LIKE 2005 THANK YOU DAS I CAN REST EASY