So here's what I'm getting at:
Magus bans Tony because of ban evasion, AND not following rules.
Tony's defense is that he likes one of those hardcore edgy medieval RPs, and will do it at his expense, even if it means doing the acts he recently committed, if not more.
Buddy, you're forgeted. And considering that you seem to be getting off on this kind of stuff, I think I can consider it old news. This isn't the first time you've had a major hard-on from even the most oddest of topics.