Poll

is she

no
1 (25%)
thhee fooorce is stROOONNNGG innn yooouuu...................... ......
3 (75%)

Total Members Voted: 4

Author Topic: real talk: is rey a mary sue  (Read 4932 times)

Rey is definitely a mary sue. The actor herself also isn't the best either.

On the topic of the prequels why the forget did Lucas make episode 1 about a trade embargo due to over taxation? That stuff is interesting in an encyclopedia, not in a movie, and even if it could be Lucas isn't smart enough to make something like that interesting.

Rey is definitely a mary sue. The actor herself also isn't the best either.

On the topic of the prequels why the forget did Lucas make episode 1 about a trade embargo due to over taxation? That stuff is interesting in an encyclopedia, not in a movie, and even if it could be Lucas isn't smart enough to make something like that interesting.

I thought there was some nice political cynicism in there.

Seemed pretty daft to me and it's clear that Lucas only understands politics on a very surface level.

1) why are all of your opinions garbage
2) did you think that star wars before disney was what, a nonprofit organization? of forgetin course it's a corporate product. they're selling movies. all movies do this.

my opinion on your opinion on my opinions is that your opinion is garbage.

the forget? why the forget do you think people loved Star Wars in the first place? It wasn't a corporate product, it was an incredible adventure with memorably amazing characters and a captivating story with fantastic visuals. The Force Recycled was the opposite of that.

my opinion on your opinion on my opinions is that your opinion is garbage.

the forget? why the forget do you think people loved Star Wars in the first place? It wasn't a corporate product, it was an incredible adventure with memorably amazing characters and a captivating story with fantastic visuals. The Force Recycled was the opposite of that.


Dude the prequels were entirely corporate and made to sell toys.

the forget? why the forget do you think people loved Star Wars in the first place? It wasn't a corporate product, it was an incredible adventure with memorably amazing characters and a captivating story with fantastic visuals. The Force Recycled was the opposite of that.
i dunno what you're talking about. star wars is and always was a corporate product designed to make money, just like basically every movie that ends up in theaters.

Dude the prequels were entirely corporate and made to sell toys.

you're telling me George only made them to sell toys and not because he had a passion for Star Wars and wanted to bring it back to a new generation?

the forget? why the forget do you think people loved Star Wars in the first place? It wasn't a corporate product, it was an incredible adventure with memorably amazing characters and a captivating story with fantastic visuals. The Force Recycled was the opposite of that.
he just told you why that was not true. the point of movie-making is money-making.

you're telling me George only made them to sell toys and not because he had a passion for Star Wars and wanted to bring it back to a new generation?
both

you're telling me George only made them to sell toys and not because he had a passion for Star Wars and wanted to bring it back to a new generation?
he wanted to make money. because he's a director and its his job. maybe he likes his job a lot and wants to make a legitimately good piece of art, but he can't keep doing that if his movie makes no money.

you're both missing the point here.

*sigh*

you're telling me George only made them to sell toys and not because he had a passion for Star Wars and wanted to bring it back to a new generation?

Yes. Have you seen footage of him while he was directing? There was no passion or thought put into the prequels. He just sat in the directors chair sipping his coffee. And of course he only used green screens and not real locations because putting effort into your film that you have 10x the budget for compared to your previous, better work is hard :C

you're both missing the point here.

*sigh*
god forbid you actually explain yourself then

god forbid you actually explain yourself then

you dont have a high enough iq to understand the prequels.

On the topic of the prequels why the forget did Lucas make episode 1 about a trade embargo due to over taxation? That stuff is interesting in an encyclopedia, not in a movie
The problem is that the dialogue is a bit too focused on the wrong issue.

Palpatine is a Senator who is in good position to become the Chancellor of the entire Republic. He wants to enact war-time protocols to boost his popularity and also increase his diplomatic powers, so he can begin laying the ground work for future events.

War-Time requires an actual war, so he plays the Evil Creepy Master Dude to the Trade Federation, promising them power for allegiance. The Trade Federation then begins cutting off supplies to Naboo, insisting that the Queen sign some ridiculous, insane contract. She ain't going to do that, so she sends word back to Coruscant, head of the Republic, and Palpatine moves to send some Jedi "Negotiators" to "Resolve" the situation.

The Jedi start a stuff-storm, and the Trade Federation's leaders escape and mount their forces for an all out assault on many multiple planets, enlisting the help of other large scale organisations in Palpatine's pocket.

The problem is that a lot of the dialogue is spent focusing on the embargo and the contract in political terms. You wouldn't really need to change much to fix those parts of Phantom Menace (the real issue is everything to do with Anakin).

Yes. Have you seen footage of him while he was directing? There was no passion or thought put into the prequels. He just sat in the directors chair sipping his coffee.
So, you're telling me that a director was acting like...a director? The forget do you think they do on set? Their job is to oversee the production and make sure ALL members of staff, cast and crew, are performing their duties. He was focusing on the actors to ensure they hit their marks, looking for areas to improve. He was making sure the lighting and cameras were set correctly. He had his mind on the game. I'm not sure what kind of handicapped point you're making here.

And of course he only used green screens and not real locations because putting effort into your film that you have 10x the budget for compared to your previous, better work is hard :C
How many locations in the prequel trilogy could have actually been shot in real locations? Why does it even matter filming in the real world? With the power of modern CGI (which is all thanks to enhancements from ILM, BTW), there really is no excuse for not at the very least digitally enhancing any sequence for a large-scale space opera. The prequels wanted to take us to places we've never been before, and they did.

Besides, you're presuming a lot to say they only used green screens, and it's flat out not true.

Dude the prequels were entirely corporate and made to sell toys.
Grow up.



But you are Darth Revan?
Get it? Because KOTOR and the one flashback you get early in the story?