I know it sounds really stuffty right now, but the computer that got 5/5 had been praised and downloaded a lot more than any other computer (that I am aware of) so far - plus its a site about events. I hear what your saying, I shouldn't give my computers really high marks, but that doesn't mean I should give them really low marks because I made them either.
Also I was kinda harsh on the Wind. Its not like I made all of my builds get really high star marks.
On another note I am willing to modify the reviews to your opinions until I get the comment box working. What would you rate the IcyDesktop1000/10001 (and don't be a douche bag and type -1)