I hate Chesse as much as the next guy but I'm not trying to crucify Emer. The only reason you're not doing "if" questions is because you know you're wrong.
"If Chesse hands in a good app, will you admit him?"
Chesse won't. If I know much about the person being questioned, I won't answer the if question.
If you want an answer, fine. I would not vote on his app at all.