i dunno i really liked saints row
it's sort of a clusterforget and really tongue-in-cheek but the gameplay is solid, the plot gets pretty funny and the characters are tolerable at worst to fun (to mess with or otherwise) at best
like it's not a realistic crime drama but i don't know what you expected considering there is a scene where literally a stuff-ton of hookers rush a bunch of pseudo-mafia-dudes armed with nothing but a bunch of carrotbats and sheer unrelenting moxie