I fully understand that a lot of people like melee over brawl, but seriously. Melee was relatively broken. I recently played melee and my god is it unresponsive. Kirby could barely move in the air without his jumps, items were a bitch to pick up, smash attacks were far more difficult to launch without the C-stick, ugh it was unbearable. I loved melee at one point, but then brawl came out. Brawl is like melee, only a small bit slower paced and much more responsive to whatever you press. Hell, it has the addition of wolf, who I play much better with than fox and falco. And if you really can't stand the slow paced fighting style, get brawl plus. It isn't melee, sure, but it wasn't made for that anyways. It's just a faster brawl with more hitstun (and a forgeted up yoshi who can recover even less, but regardless).
I'm not a person who rages about opinions, but I'll just add the bolded below. I also don't hate brawl, but I just don't think it matches up to Melee.
1. Not really. I find it far more responsive than Brawl.
2. In what way? Can't pick them up in the air? Yes, you can.
3. I find myself doing smash attacks unpurposely while doing tilt attacks in Brawl. And C-stick is for pussies, except when trying to Meteor Smash/Spike.
4. It's really slow paced, win-by-one-attack and way too easy to recover in.
5. Another copy character to the roster.
6. No.
7. Yoshi sucks regardless.
Let's not start any kind of argument, and just leave our opinions to ourselves, unless you really want to start raging about such a little thing.
What in the hell? Really? Windwaker above OOT? Majora's Mask wasn't even that good either.
Opinions. Personally, I think OoT < MM