Re: HERP DERP ATHEISM

[Wizard]

Exactly, you put a good or bad example someone is bound to follow it.

But you already gave me an example with a preconceived notion of morality. And what about this situation: say there's a burning house with two babies in it, you can only save one, which do you save?

1.I agree with your post. But people making up gods helped them make more Morales.
2.No, Right and wrong is what a person thinks is right and wrong.

1. That doesn't mean the god is real or needed in a modern context.
2. So if I decide it's OK to kill you that's all good?

[Ad Bot]

[TeslaCoil]

But you already gave me an example with a preconceived notion of morality. And what about this situation: say there's a burning house with two babies in it, you can only save one, which do you save?

Both or die trying.

[Wizard]

Both or die trying.

You can only save one. If you die trying neither is saved AND you die.

[goobler402]

1. That doesn't mean the god is real or needed in a modern context.
2. So if I decide it's OK to kill you that's all good?

1.I never said he was real
2.To you, it's good, to others, it's not.

[Wizard]

1.I never said he was real
2.To you, it's good, to others, it's not.

So are you saying I should be able to murder you and then justify it because it was good "to me"?

[dkamm65]

So are you saying I should be able to murder you and then justify it because it was good "to me"?

[Antallion]

Ateism*

[TeslaCoil]

You can only save one. If you die trying neither is saved AND you die.

So let me assess the situation.

You are obviously alone and there is a house that is burning with 2 babies in it. I can only save  one.

I am obviously without outside help and I know neither of them.

By saving one it would be unfair to the other.

By trying to save both I "might" end up dead along with both of them.

This leaves a huge paradox in my mind.

I suppose the best would be to try and save one, and then try to come back for the other as fast as possible.

The only thing I can think of.

[Man 2]

Ateism*

Are you serious?

[IkeTheGeneric]

God exists because he doesn't exist

End of story

[dkamm65]

So let me assess the situation.

You are obviously alone and there is a house that is burning with 2 babies in it. I can only save  one.

I am obviously without outside help and I know neither of them.

By saving one it would be unfair to the other.

By trying to save both I "might" end up dead along with both of them.

This leaves a huge paradox in my mind.

I suppose the best would be to try and save one, and then try to come back for the other as fast as possible.

The only thing I can think of.

Eeny, meeny, miny, moe.

[TeslaCoil]

Eeny, meeny, miny, moe.

I could try that too.

[Wizard]

That's the point. If there was a moral giving god there'd be one clear answer to the situation.

[*Magick* Mage]

God works in mysterious ways.

And humans are his darkest mystery.


That's all I could come up with in the last 20 minutes. :I

[Man 2]

Humans suck.