Author Topic: Crossbow study: Best materials  (Read 5518 times)

After reading so many different opinions on what the best wood for a crossbow was, I decided to find out on my own.  My test would be simple.  Make a crossbow out of each wood, all with the same metal, than see which one fired the farthest.

First, I had to choose a metal.  I wanted something readily available, and cheap.  So, I went with rust.

Second, I had to get enough wood to make crossbows with each type.  There are nine types of wood.

1. Maple
2. Walnut
3. Flakeboard
4. Beech
5. Pine
6. Cherry
7. Oak
8. Teak
9. Cork

For the test, all I had to do was remain stationary while I fired each crossbow: 

First, I fired one several times, to make sure that the speed and distance remained constant, it did.

Second, I went through every crossbow, intending to note which ones fired noticeably further than the rest, and retry those.

After firing all nine crossbows, I found that the speed and distance of the bolt still remained constant.

Verdict:  Wood makes absolutely no difference when building a crossbow.

Next test, metals.  Gathering the necessary supplies once again, may take awhile, so don't expect a reply for a week or so.

Metals...who cares plutonium is the best.

Primary Metal/Secondary Metal/Wood

Primary Metal- Determines length of shot. Plutonium is the best.
Secondary Metal- Does nothing.
Wood- Does nothing.

You could have saved yourself a lot of time on the wood part by just reading the forums a bit to see if the wood in the xbows determine anything (which they don't :P).

Now, the metal part I'm curious about. I'm nearly positive that somewhere there should be a post about which metals do what in xbows or something, but I suggest you continue the tests anyway just for the hell of it. What's a game when you have nothing to do, eh? Good luck.

I peeked around the forums a bit, didn't bother doing a full on search.  I figured what the hey, I'll do the test myself.

I would assume plutonium would be the best as well, considering how difficult it is to get a substantial amount of it.  But, again, I'd rather see for myself.

I can say, though, that rust sucks.  =P

I guess I could double check on the secondary metal.

On a side note, I've heard several rumors about gold swords giving more money.  As far as I can tell, it makes absolutely no difference.  A sword is a sword is a sword in AoT.  Don't bother wasting your time or money trying to get a gold sword.  Instead, make one that you like the appearance of.

Metal Heirarchy.

Plut, Steel, Gold/Iron, Others.

I thought the second metal was reload rate and wood was damage or vice versa...at least that's what Mew said and she was a crossbow master...

She read the AoT website, wood was supposed to be accuracy, second metal fireing rate, promary power.

Well, secondary metal means squat as well.  The only factor in a crossbow is the primary metal.

When I get enough hematite to make some steel, plus the money to make all the crossbows (probably much sooner than the hema =P), I'll post on that.

After crossbows, shields!

We already know about shields, at least most of them.   Also, I have some steel.  (lol snake it's ours)

Haha, yeah, our steel deal after the reset.  First with steel shields!

Actually I just made mine a month ago,  but it's made from ancient steel.  It's part of my PvP set, a Steel Shield and a Gold Sword.

LOL I have the best crossbow in the game and I only bought it for 800 gp :P

I have the oldest plut crossbow, sit noob.

I'm probably the oldest creepph-..  I mean, player on the server.  Noob....

:D

Well, original magic Xbow was Plutonium for primary, gold for trim and cherry for wood. That's what I have.