Poll

Which is better?

Red Dead Redemption
23 (65.7%)
Grand Theft Auto IV
12 (34.3%)

Total Members Voted: 35

Author Topic: Red Dead Redemption vs Grand Theft Auto IV  (Read 2640 times)

I was referring to GTA4 not RDR. I haven't played RDR but I watched gameplay vids and it doesn't interest me.
I said the exact same thing before I played it. I thought it looked boring as stuff.

I said the exact same thing before I played it. I thought it looked boring as stuff.

Really? Well I'd try it if there was a demo but oh well. I'll try do more research on RDR.

Really? Well I'd try it if there was a demo but oh well. I'll try do more research on RDR.
John Marston is sent out to get his old outlaw buddies and lots of bitches get shot. /game It was fun

Im currently have both games out on gamefly. I've had GTAIV out for some time now and is like 8 missions untill the ending according to the wiki but I have been playing RDR and have just finished the part in mexico where that soldier guy betrays you in the church. I've enjoyed RDR more overall.

One thing I  do hate about RDR's multiplayer though is that when you're doing a gang hideout and just trying to level there's always friends trying to come in and kill you no matter what. I was doing the tumbleweed gang hideout and 2 guys in the same posse were waiting for me outside. I could hear them saying stuff on their mics like "Oh, I think he knows we're here." or "You go in the main entrance I'll go in the basement". Or stuff along the lines of that. Good thing they never killed me, I escaped and transported to another town. I've also have had guys chase me through the entire map just to kill and then continue to spawn kill me. They haven't succeeded, at least yet, though.

One thing I  do hate about RDR's multiplayer though is that when you're doing a gang hideout and just trying to level there's always friends trying to come in and kill you no matter what. I was doing the tumbleweed gang hideout and 2 guys in the same posse were waiting for me outside. I could hear them saying stuff on their mics like "Oh, I think he knows we're here." or "You go in the main entrance I'll go in the basement". Or stuff along the lines of that. Good thing they never killed me, I escaped and transported to another town. I've also have had guys chase me through the entire map just to kill and then continue to spawn kill me. They haven't succeeded, at least yet, though.
I always see people that seem passive then just shoot me in the face

meh, i liked rdr more
and yes theyre the same loving genre, you can judge them
theyre made by the same company
and rdr is basically gta with cowboys
so shush
and online in rdr is kickass
release it for pc, rockstar

I always see people that seem passive then just shoot me in the face

This makes me not want to buy the game.

This makes me not want to buy the game.
Get friends to also buy the game and this won't happen really

I always see people that seem passive then just shoot me in the face
Yes, it's very annoying.

This makes me not want to buy the game.
Why? Just cause of a few annoyances in multiplayer? Singleplayer is really where this game wins and strives for, and the multiplayer is just an epic bonus.

The multiplayer is still fun, just be sure to be in a posse with some friends. Lone wonderers are usually the target for other posses to gang up on.

RDR should have a DDR mode.


DDR?
dance dance revolution


also, me and greekgeeker play gta online all the time. he drives and i shoot.

One thing I  do hate about RDR's multiplayer though is that when you're doing a gang hideout and just trying to level there's always friends trying to come in and kill you no matter what. I was doing the tumbleweed gang hideout and 2 guys in the same posse were waiting for me outside. I could hear them saying stuff on their mics like "Oh, I think he knows we're here." or "You go in the main entrance I'll go in the basement". Or stuff along the lines of that. Good thing they never killed me, I escaped and transported to another town. I've also have had guys chase me through the entire map just to kill and then continue to spawn kill me. They haven't succeeded, at least yet, though.
Same happens to me. They always shoot my donkey and it makes me sad. Their High Power Pistols are too strong, damn Colt.