Two game ideas--which one do I pick?

[Kingdaro]

Using the Love2D engine, I am going to develop a rhythm/music game. However, I really don't want to work on two different projects at once, maybe you guys could help me out.

1) Beat Jam - A piano type game where you control five keys and hit the corresponding key as the notes fall down to a red bar that marks when they are to be pressed.

2) Mouse Mania - Arrows fly to a circle to the right-center of the screen where you must move your mouse in the arrow's direction once the arrow is in the circle. Then there are clicks--which have the appearance of a circle similar to the receptor circle--where you must (if it isn't obvious already) click the mouse once they have reached the center, left or right.

Which one should I go with? In other words, which one would you think would be more fun?

[Ad Bot]

[Ayxrion]

i would do mouse mania, looks really fun
Beat jam, i dont care

[Kingdaro]

I kind of wanted to do Mouse Mania myself too, actually.

[Chrono]

Second one sounds more interesting.

[Freeze]

Second one is more original.

[Kingdaro]

Second one sounds more interesting.

It does.

Second one is more original.

Good point.

[DrenDran]

1) Beat Jam - A piano type game where you control five keys and hit the corresponding key as the notes fall down to a red bar that marks when they are to be pressed.

Gee, that hasn't already been a hundred times already, has it?

[Kingdaro]

I'm starting to think that the two shouldn't even be compared to each other. >.>

[dkamm65]

So is this Beat Jam a ripoff of Jamlegend which has a mode in which you control five keys and hit the corresponding key as the notes fall down to a bar that marks when they are to be pressed, which is also cleverly titled Beat Jam?

[Kingdaro]

So is this Beat Jam a ripoff of Jamlegend which has a mode in which you control five keys and hit the corresponding key as the notes fall down to a bar that marks when they are to be pressed, which is also cleverly titled Beat Jam?

What's Jamlegend?

Edit: Googled it, f**k.

[aml]

Second one reminds me of guided missile.

Edit: Here it is.

[yogamoanyo]

Beat Jam is like others said, just a copy of JamLegend


Mouse Mania sounds like Osu!

[Kingdaro]

Mouse Mania sounds like Osu!

Mouse Mania is not like OSU. You're moving the mouse in a direction, and not to a location.

[yogamoanyo]

Mouse Mania is not like OSU. You're moving the mouse in a direction, and not to a location.

It's sounds like Osu! the way you explained it.

[Kingdaro]

The attached image is an effortlessly thrown together image of what Mouse Mania would look like.