Rookie being a troll really depends on what you consider a troll, I would not consider cheezy unfunny jokes constantly trolling, as he is not trying to make anyone mad. People get mad that he is unfunny which is quite stupid and blow it all out of proportion. I'm not sure if this annoying display Rookie puts on is really enough to make people hate him, or if they just see him as an easy target to attack to boost their e-fame. I'd much rather get rid of all the starfishs trying to start wars in every thread than all the immature annoying users.