Poll

Ban circumcision of children that obviously cannot make their own decisions?

yes
23 (52.3%)
no
21 (47.7%)

Total Members Voted: 44

Author Topic: Female Genital Mutilation/Cutting_ OP updated with information  (Read 10259 times)

dog snakees what

i got circumcised and i my rooster doesnt look like a dog's
Shut up, dog snake.

Cut what off the richard?

now i know never to date an african chick

now i know never to date an african chick
That comes straight from africa.

the reason this isn't okay but circumcision is  is the same reason why women don't have to sign up for draft.
The new dumbest thing I've heard all day.
Women should be included in the draft.
And all child/involuntary circumcision should be made illegal, it's a terrible, barbaric practice.

The new dumbest thing I've heard all day.
Women should be included in the draft.
And all child/involuntary circumcision should be made illegal, it's a terrible, barbaric practice.
qft
« Last Edit: January 18, 2011, 11:39:41 PM by Valen »

And all child/involuntary circumcision should be made illegal, it's a terrible, barbaric practice.
What about those who have religious or health reasons for doing it?  Besides, it hurts a hell of a lot less to have it as a baby than an adult, lol.

What about those who have religious or health reasons for doing it?  Besides, it hurts a hell of a lot less to have it as a baby than an adult, lol.
Religious reasons? Well, it's wrong to press religion on young children anyway.
Health reasons? If someone *needs* it to live, then yes.

D:

Poor helpless children who have this forced upon them.

Quote
It can result in death through severe bleeding leading to haemorrhagic shock, neurogenic shock as a result of pain and trauma, and severe, overwhelming infection and septicaemia. It is routinely traumatic. Many girls enter a state of shock induced by the severe pain, psychological trauma and exhaustion from screaming.

I feel dizzy and disgusted.

Religious reasons? Well, it's wrong to press religion on young children anyway.
Let me tell you my situation.  My parents are Jewish, but not strictly so.  They believe that I can make whatever choice I want in my religion.  I am currently atheist.  However, when I was younger, I went to a Jewish religious school.  Not because my parents wanted me Jewish, but because they wanted me to have knowledge of a religion, if only for the experience.  They could have easily sent me to a Christian school for the same reasons.  In a way, this ties into circumcision.  If I had decided later in life to become Jewish, it would have been far more painful to get circumcised.  

Just to add in, I think that your opinion of it being a barbaric practice is somewhat narrow-minded.  Its only the unfortunate 1% who have problems, and usually that is because of some crappy fake doctor.

Also, why is this topic drifting to male genital cutting? Lol, funny how this forum works.

Let me tell you my situation.  My parents are Jewish, but not strictly so.  They believe that I can make whatever choice I want in my religion.  I am currently atheist.  However, when I was younger, I went to a Jewish religious school.  Not because my parents wanted me Jewish, but because they wanted me to have knowledge of a religion, if only for the experience.  They could have easily sent me to a Christian school for the same reasons.  In a way, this ties into circumcision.  If I had decided later in life to become Jewish, it would have been far more painful to get circumcised.  

Just to add in, I think that your opinion of it being a barbaric practice is somewhat narrow-minded.  Its only the unfortunate 1% who have problems, and usually that is because of some crappy fake doctor.

Also, why is this topic drifting to male genital cutting? Lol, funny how this forum works.
It's barbaric because there is no real reason to it.

It's barbaric because there is no real reason to it.
There are religious and health reasons. 

Is any religious practice barbaric?  There's no real reason for it, is there?

Meh, this is just my opinion, you may believe what you like.

There are religious and health reasons.  

Both of those are bogus, especially when compared to the absolutely awful and disgusting medial and mental effects it has. There are no actual health reasons apart from negative ones, and the religious practice is a confusion according to the site.

Both of those are bogus, especially when compared to the absolutely awful and disgusting medial and mental effects it has.
What effects?  As far as I know, the risk is less than 1%.  And just about every medical procedure has risk, most with more than just the meager 1%.  Also, circumcision has been practiced for thousands of years.  Doesn't seem to have done much to hurt our population to me.

I'm pretty sure if there's something there, you shouldn't be chopping parts off of it with a scalpel.

I sure as hell wouldn't want someone cutting stuff off my richard.