Are we having neutral judges/viewers picking by project quality? I take issue with two factors of this award.
Problem #1: Uneducated Voting
Honestly, someone could easily just pick a clan and not know about it, but only because they heard of it. It just sounds like uneducated voting would be running rampant. I realize that there would be alot of people who would make a wise decision, but most members aren't all that knowledgeable when it comes to clans.
Problem #2: Clan Biasing
If someone is in a clan running for the award, or an ally or rival clan, most people will vote accordingly to inter-clan relationships. Many people are in these clans, and that makes a huge problem. Most people will therefore ignore or fail to acknowledge another clan’s quality. Voting by ego much?