Rebecca Black/Friday - Is she to blame? Serious discussion. Really.

[Lugnut]

I'm sure most of you have heard of her "amazing" hit 'Friday'. There was a topic a short while back. Anyway, the internet community, (Everyone who cares that is) is fuming over how bad it is, and how bad her voice is, and autotune is only making it worse.  

Look at it this way,  

• Is it her fault her voice is bad?
• Is it her fault she sang such a stupid song? Did she write it?
• How about Justin Bieber? Is he as bad as he says?

  Personally, I think she/her parents are doing it for the money, and she didn't really have a say. This topic was mainly made because I haven't seen a single person more than three people defend her.

On Lolbot, I saw a post detailing how a person knew a person who knew her personally. They described how her voice wasn't that bad, and how she was intending to do drama/plays, but instead was forced into pop singing. The lolbot source is about as credible as wikipedia, but still, if there is any credibility, what does that say for her?

What about this interview between her and Good Morning America?

Frankly, I don't think her voice is that bad. That isn't to say that her 'singing voice' isn't balls, but maybe she isn't that bad. The video clearly sucks. A lot.

Discuss.
tl;dr forget you read it

EDIT Reason 1: Forgot to link the video from GMA
EDIT 2: Changed title in a small way.

[Ad Bot]

[.::Taboo::.]

it's her fault for making that stuff at all.

[Iban]

Girls just wanna have FUN FUN.

[Stocking]

Well no one is to blame for liking her stuff, she's easily the Emily richardinson or the Robert Frost of our generation. マホ～

[Lugnut]

You guys seem to be misunderstanding me.
I'm not saying the video is good, nor am I trying to be her and say she likes her stuff.
My question is this
is she the criminal here?
Yes, I know, even the passenger gets a ticket or whatever the forget it is, but still.

it's her fault for making that stuff at all.

There are people who have been forced into work. I can't name any off of the top of my head, but still.

[Anti-Block]

Am I the only one who thinks this song infects your brain faster than the plague?

[Night Fox]

[Stocking]

You guys seem to be misunderstanding me.
I'm not saying the video is good, nor am I trying to be her and say she likes her stuff.
My question is this
is she the criminal here?

I think she actually sounds better and writes more coherently than most of the metal the guys here listen to. マホ～

[.::Taboo::.]

is she the criminal here?

it's her fault for making that stuff at all.

[Lugnut]

[img]http://mirror1.lolbot.net/mirror.php?img=14427.gif/img]

Saw that, lol'd
wanted to say
"I TOLD YOU ABOUT STAIRS BRO
I TOLD YOU

[Lugnut]

You missed my edit.

I think she actually sounds better and writes more coherently than most of the metal the guys here listen to. マホ～

This is a true statement.

[Ningyou]

I listened to it once and was like "oh my god my ears"

[Madmitten]

I listened to it once and was like "oh my god my ears"

i thought it wasnt too bad until she said friday
and then said WE SO EXCITED

[comr4de]

At the GMA link

I say blame Ark Music Factory. They're the handicaps who actually wrote and produced the song. Rebecca's just the unlucky victim who thought she was getting her shot at 13.

Hell yes

[Lugnut]

And you know what
I commented on that comment.