This is what I have so far. I'm not good at essays and I absolutely hate it when my parents try to proof read.
btw I still have 2 more paragraphs to write :C
In Geeks bearing Gifts Renee starts out writing this paper of who she believe is outsiders. She slowly realizes that the outsiders are not who she initially believed were the outsiders. She realizes that the "outsiders" are all part of a group who hang out together, which means that the real “outsiders” are the “in-crowd”. Susan, a girl struggling to find her place, strongly believes in the concept of 'What Would Jesus Do'. She is constantly showing forgiveness to the antagonist, who continuously bullies her, despite her compassion. When the antagonist breaks her wood shop project, Susan decides to walk out onto a frozen pond, just to pass the time, and she brings the antagonist with her. The rather malevolent side of Susan begins to come out of the woodwork, when the antagonist falls in and instead of helping him, she calmly says, “Jesus couldn’t save everyone”. Events in people’s life can change the person, for better or for worse. Renee, who believes the “outsiders” are the weird kids, gay kids, or the teenage moms, changes her mind and becomes friends with many of them. It seems that Renee changed for the better. Susan, on the other hand, seems to change for the worse. She is so upset that the antagonist, Joey, broke her wood shop project that she stops forgiving and lets him drown.
Renee, the previously mentioned character who was fond of misjudging people, is the protagonist. She is doing a report on who she believes to be “outsiders”. She spends time with them and after talking with them so much, she realizes they are not outsiders at all. She notices how practically everyone is condescending to these kids, and that these kids are judged because of who they are or what they’ve done. It is a sad fact, because people shouldn't have to change who they are to meet somebody else's standards. With this realization comes a change of heart and mind for Renee. Gaining a new aspect on how the social classes of her school have oppressed those "weird kids" who are all wonderful people. Renne learns not to judge people until she has gotten to know them, and spent some real time with them.
In WWJD Susan is the protagonist. She is bullied constantly by the antagonist Eddie. Eddie keeps bullying her but she keeps forgiving him. She gets the chance to get Eddie kicked out of the school but doesn’t take the opportunity and says she forgave him. Eddie didn’t understand and he took it too far with the bullying, destroying her wood work project. She gets very upset and walks out onto this thing ice. Eddie was edging her on asking if she was gonna kill herself. She tells Eddie to come out onto the ice and he does, but he falls through. She walks over to where Eddie has fallen threw and sits there, watching him, just out of reach. She says “Jesus couldn’t save everyone”
I edited most of it, the last paragraph I'm not going to bother with, but there's a lot i can say already, so here we go:
There isn't much structure to this essay. You've introduced a lot of ideas multiple times, so the first two paragraphs are virtually the same information, although the second is expanded. The essay is out of order, and things seem to be described and discussed at random. The key to keeping an organized paper that is easy to follow, and gets your point across, is to follow a simple format:
Introduction
-includes thesis statement, summarizing main points of the essay
1st body paragraph
-intro sentence
-concrete detail, quote from the text
-discussion of the detail
-another CD
-more discussion
2nd body paragraph
-same as 1st
(optional, based on amount of info needed/point being discussed) 3rd body paragraph
-same as 1 and 2
Conclusion
-re-state thesis
-bring ideas to a close
Alrighty then. You also need to limit how much introductory information you're giving. You don't want the essay to be a summary of the book, although you do need some context. So I would limit that background information to only what is relative, and an overall introduction to the book should take no more than a sentence.
You're not getting your point across very well. It's not clear what you're trying to tell us, when we read it.
Bottom line:
This essay needs a stuff ton of work if you expect a good grade on it. Not sure what grade you're in, but if you get all this info about essay's down pat before too long, high school english (and college i guess) will be easier. There's a lot more to work on, but start with that. Let me know if you want extended help on it, I'm a pretty good editor.
Thanks to dorkdot for the grammatical corrections. Content is most important, so try to focus on that as well.