Do people have the right to claim clips they took from another show on youtube?

[Lørd Tøny]

This guy is telling me that his video clip is his and that he wants my video taken down. But he has no right to the clips as they are owned by PBS kids.

Who exactly is right in this situation?

[Ad Bot]

[Supersylox]

Um

If you took his video, and didnt ask for the footage HE recorded, Then hes right.

However, if you recorded it yourself, then he has no right to demand that.

Oh, and curiosity forces me to ask: what's the video?

[SlayerZ99]

Um

If you took his video, and didnt ask for the footage HE recorded, Then hes right.

However, if you recorded it yourself, then he has no right to demand that.

Oh, and curiosity forces me to ask: what's the video?

No I think he means
PBS published a video

both of them took the video and re-posted

other guy acusses him of stealing "his" video

[Supersylox]

No I think he means
PBS published a video

both of them took the video and re-posted

other guy acusses him of stealing "his" video

Oh

Then if thats the case

They're both wrong for stealing the content.

[Kalphiter]

The video in question: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zhVxT8bs5-4

[Supersylox]

The video in question: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zhVxT8bs5-4

Some of my brain cells just died.

[zookuw]

He is angry because you literally downloaded the video and riposted the same one onto youtube again

OP is a friend.

[Kevdude]

OP is a friend.

We knew this already

[Lørd Tøny]

He is angry because you literally downloaded the video and riposted the same one onto youtube again

OP is a friend.

I actually found it off a website.

[Black and White]

Oh

Then if thats the case

They're both wrong for stealing the content.

unless tony is claiming he made the video from scratch witch I highly doubt then I'd say he's in the right

[Skorpion]

Oh

Then if thats the case

They're both wrong for stealing the content.

Not really. They are not taking credit for it it.
If PBS wants it taken down, they can ask youtube.
But the other person claims it's his video, which is a lie.
They both just posted it on youtube so people can watch it anytime

[dkamm65]

You wrote that reply wrong. It should say "Unless you own or have rights to PBS Kid's Arthur then you don't have full authority to seize control [of] and/or remove my video."

[Supersylox]

Not really. They are not taking credit for it it.
If PBS wants it taken down, they can ask youtube.
But the other person claims it's his video, which is a lie.
They both just posted it on youtube so people can watch it anytime

Ah, okay.

[Lørd Tøny]

You wrote that reply wrong. It should say "Unless you own or have rights to PBS Kid's Arthur then you don't have full authority to seize control [of] and/or remove my video."

Ah, I knew I forgeted something up.

Oh well I fixed the video so the issue seems to be solved for now.

[Lørd Tøny]

Update.

Is this supposed to be a joke? While I hold no legal claims to Arthur and clips thereof, it's rather annoying to have somebody take your idea and attempt to take credit for it. I asked my friend who showed me the original episode if I could post it on my account, then edited it to have the clip I do now, and gave him credit for finding the thing in the first place.

You, on the other hand, took what I had edited myself without permission, posting it as your own thing, and never even gave me credit. That's just downright wrong. If you had asked, I probably would have given you the link to the episode or allowed you to -edit- my clip and use it for your own purposes, or even make a new video for you to use. But instead you insult me like this.

Now what do I do?