I don't think you ever watched anything else than Lucky Star. There's plenty of anime that don't have the big ass eyes girls.
Yes yes, when they feel real creative they anti the massive eye girth into their hair.
But.. Ive never heard of "Lucky Star"
If every movie/TV show or whatever was realistic, God, I would never watch anything.
That's the whole idea of movies/TV shows/comics, mostly the best ones are fantasy and things that won't happen in real life. Because real life is boring compared to a fantasy you yourself can create and where anything is possible.
I never said that shows that aren't realistic were bad, I just said that the anime style annoys me.