Despite the fact that I don't really like Eussorus because he tried to say the only method of flight is a hot-air balloon (AKA: the only method of chat is events), I have to agree with him in that this is taking it a bit far. There was already a thread for this, so why the hell would you make another?
If I were to run with the starfish = murderer brown townogy, it would be like trying to prove him guilty twice.