Middle Finger in Sesame Street

[LOL :D]

[Ad Bot]

[Mikoyan]

Looks like the index

[_Rave_]

dude how do you even mess that up

[LOL :D]

Here's a better picture:

[Cybertails1998]

is that Elmo with hair

[Isaac Fox]

Here's a better picture:

-snip-

That circle you keep drawing makes it impossible to tell if it's really the middle finger or just the index.

[Jetlok]

is that Elmo with hair

no that guy's upper arm is just made of hair like that
god people can be so inconsiderate

[Jairo]

mr rogers

[Ceist]

"and forget you too, bill"

[Eussorus]

he was showing the audience which finger he fingers himself with.

[grunterdb1951]

she was showing the audience which finger she fingers herself with.

But its a guy...

[Eussorus]

he was showing the audience which finger he fingers himself with.

fixed.

[dorkdotdan]

he was showing the audience which finger he fingers himself with.

You're thinking of Mr. McFeely