Author Topic: Do I write good?  (Read 3910 times)

I have such a hard time being simplistic and not being too simplistic that its just a shallow story or vice versa that I'm trying a bit too hard to accomplish what I want to. That perfect balance I haven't found out, which is giving me a hard time...
In my opinion it is better to be too shallow then to be too descriptive at first. That way the reader can implement his own imagination in it instead of it being completely thought out.

In my opinion it is better to be too shallow then to be too descriptive at first. That way the reader can implement his own imagination in it instead of it being completely thought out.
Its been my Achilles heel, I'm naturally an overconcious and overthought person and that reflects over to my writing which tends to blossom into an elaborate enigma which most people would not get any sustanence of a story from.

On top of that, I'm a perfectionist. Whatever isn't right won't be right till its fixed, and I have to hit the bullseye almost immediately or I'm unsatisfied.

But yeah, I see where you're going with being too shallow at first and then later beckoning over the deeper details. Its probably the surrealism of The Book Thief by Mark Zusack getting to me, it seems to be a good head off; but I must be aiming a bit high.


You can practice not being so descriptive by taking your post you just made, and dumbing it down a tad.

Its been my Achilles heel, I'm naturally an overconcious and overthought person and that reflects over to my writing which tends to blossom into an elaborate enigma which most people would not get any sustanence of a story from.

On top of that, I'm a perfectionist. Whatever isn't right won't be right till its fixed, and I have to hit the bullseye almost immediately or I'm unsatisfied.

But yeah, I see where you're going with being too shallow at first and then later beckoning over the deeper details. Its probably the surrealism of The Book Thief by Mark Zusack getting to me, it seems to be a good head off; but I must be aiming a bit high.

I don't like writing too simply. It just bugs me that theres a majority of books listed as ten year olds but more like eight year old writing.

Perfectionism, otherwise known as must be perfect all the time syndrome, comes from my mother and my strive to have everything just the way its supposed to be... in my mind.

?

Lol yeh that was pretty simple.

YOU MEAN DO I WRITE WELL. I DIDN'T EVEN READ THE MOST LIKELY stuffTY STORY BECAUSE OF THAT.

YOU MEAN DO I WRITE WELL. I DIDN'T EVEN READ THE MOST LIKELY stuffTY STORY BECAUSE OF THAT.
wowe

it's a pretty good story actually lol

Prolly going to continue like I always have. Maybe some more posts, but thanks anyways.

change the title to "am good write yes?"
people will get mad

>>>Do I write well.

Just finished a little opener for a story about my life in Blockland. I've been having a lot of trouble writing due to not being able to find any other good writers to help me, so I brought my work to Blockland forums. My first post was derailed and well died a catastrophic death, but I hope that this post gets at least a few good pointers on where to go1.

Enjoy!

Joxus and Company

I sit in a train station. My old plastic bones and stiff rubber skin now cling to me like a prison. I wear a meager trench coat, to cover up my many scars, blisters,2 and bruises that rampage3 across my body. I’ve seen a lot over the years, and as I listen to the quiet chatter of clan members preparing for some kind of war against another clan4 and the younger men fiddling with their tools trying to straighten them out; I remember my glory days.

The bench I sit on is propped against a long wall, made of sleek metal.5 The floor, a nice concrete with a bluish tint. People pass me by, all sorts of shapes and sizes and ages, as they hurry off to their respectable6 trains. I remember the old train station, how it used to look fifty some years ago, but its7 all a fading memory. Suddenly, I notice a child has moved next to me.

I turn to face him, his small warm radiance I can feel8 as he stares at me with those compassionate9 and honest brown eyes. He has a mess of brown hair covered by a little lopsided cloth cap.10 His clothing consists of a wool jacket and a scarf that he has pulled down to expose his mouth. The air is frosty, and his rosy cheeks glow with the cold. I look at him with my old eyes, deep turquoise eyes that have seen the tests of time.11

He asks me a question.12

“What are you doing here mister?” he says tentatively. I can feel he’s quite nervous of talking to strangers, probably because of his mother. Out of sight, out of mind.13

“Reeling in the years, seeing the sights and remembering the good old days.” I say matter-of-factly. I sigh a bit, I’ve always been a wonder at confusing people.

He stares at me blankly, and14 then a flash of recognition crosses him. He perks up, and deftly15 whips out an answer.16

“You must be a famous person.” he says, whipping out a small satchel cleverly hidden in his coat. He pulls out a notebook and pen, and tells me; “Write me a story, I can sit here for a while.”

I look at him apprehensively, and he stares back at me a bit blankly.17 When he starts to see that I may not do as he wants, *he flashes me a cheeky little smile, and proffers18 me the notebook and pen. I grapple19 the pen with my mechanical hand;20 the replacement for my tired21 old hook.

I look at him again, his face so alive and alight with the joy of this moment. Its close to Christmas, for all I know, but this may be a blessing for him and me. With a few deft strokes, I write the title.

Joxus and Company.

The boy watches me, eager to know my secrets. I watch him as I document my story. The words of an era that have passed untouched and unnoticed by this small little soul.22 I begin the first chapter of my life leaving my parents.23

*Added a space here.
Well.  There are a few errors that I have found.  One huge one being the title, but some others are word usage issues and preferences that do not match up.

Here we go.

1.  Revise to:  "where I need to go.", "where to go to." or "what I need to improve in." etc.  "where to go" is fairly generic, and does not express the point you are trying to get across effectively.
2.  Remove comma.
3.  The scars, blisters and bruises are not taking action in the word "rampage."  This is a very active word, and implies more than being "out of control" or generically "agressive."  A good option might be "rage."
4.  Might be too much by including "another."
5.  Is the wall or the bench made of metal?  You need to rephrase this.
6.  This word doesn't quite express the kind of "busy and diligent"  It sounds as if the people were ordered and sorted in a specific way before they were put on a train.
7.  Revise to:  "it's"
8.  Don't invert this sentence; make it more straight-forward to make it easier for the reader to read: "I can feel his small, warm radiance as he [...]"
9.  Does this boy evoke pity on the narrator?  Do you mean "Compassionate" or "Innocent?"
10.  Could be rephrased.
11.  Cleché.  Plus, the eyes are witnesses of life, not the participant.
12.  Is this meant to be all on its own?
13.  You can make this easier to understand if the adverb is used to show more shyness than experimental social initiative.  Also, there appears to be no inference to his mother before, so why is it being introduced now as if the reader was already introduced to this character?  Never make the reader assume.
14.  The conjunction "and" does not tie the two parts of the sentences together because they are not alike.  Replace with "but."
15.  Is he skillfully responding?  Revise this.
16.  The following few lines say that he is "whipping out a small satchel."  Rephrase this.  "Whipping out" is an over-active verb for quickly developing and saying something.  Also the word "answer" in incorrect, because there was nothing to reply to, however, using the word "reply" for instance, indicates that the boy is trying to continue the conversation.
17.  You said that he "stared at [me] blankly" already.  You might want to revise this line.
18.  You don't need this fancy of a word here.  Use instead:  "offers", "hands", "gives", etc.
19.  You don't need this fancy of a word here.  Use instead:  "grabs", "grasps", etc.
20.  Use a hyphen for better effect.
21.  A metal hook does not own the attributes to be tired.  Use a different word or none at all.
22.  For best effect, rewrite the line to show contrast to the narrator's eyes through experience.
23.  Rephrase.

Yes, I know that I am quite picky when it comes to this stuff, but it's a lot easier to read once certain revisions are made from the points above.

>>>Do I write well.

Just finished a little opener for a story about my life in Blockland. I've been having a lot of trouble writing due to not being able to find any other good writers to help me, so I brought my work to Blockland forums. My first post was derailed and well died a catastrophic death, but I hope that this post gets at least a few good pointers on how I should go about this.

Enjoy!

Joxus and Company

I sit in a train station. My old plastic bones and stiff rubber skin now cling to me like a prison. I wear a meager trench coat, to cover up my many scars, blisters and bruises that rage across my body. I’ve seen a lot over the years, and as I listen to the quiet chatter of clan members preparing for some kind of war against a rival clan and the younger men fiddling with their tools trying to straighten them out; I remember my glory days.

The bench I sit on is made of a sleek metal, propped against a long wall. The floor, a nice concrete with a bluish tint. People pass me by, all sorts of shapes and sizes and ages, as they hurry off to their trains. I remember the old train station, how it used to look fifty some years ago, but it's all a fading memory. Suddenly, I notice a child has moved next to me.

I turn to face him; I can feel his small warm radiance as he stares at me with those innocent and honest brown eyes. He has a mess of brown hair covered by a small lopsided cloth cap. His clothing consists of a wool jacket and a scarf that he has pulled down to expose his mouth. The air is frosty, and his rosy cheeks glow with the cold. I look at him with my old eyes, deep turquoise eyes that have seen ages of pain and regret.

He asks me a question.

“What are you doing here mister?” he says nervously. I can hear his rapid heart beat.  He quite nervous of talking to strangers.

“Reeling in the years, seeing the sights and remembering the good old days.” I say matter-of-factly. I sigh a bit, I’ve always been a wonder at confusing people.

He stares at me blankly, but then a flash of recognition crosses him. He perks up suddenly, and spews out a reply.

“You must be a famous person.” he says, whipping out a small satchel cleverly hidden in his coat. He pulls out a notebook and pen, and tells me; “Write me a story, I can sit here for a while.”

I look at him apprehensively, and he stares back at me attentively. When he starts to see that I may not do as he wants, he flashes me a cheeky little smile, and hands me the notebook and pen. I grasp the pen with my mechanical hand– the replacement for my old hook.

I look at him again, his face so alive and alight with the joy of this moment. Its close to Christmas, for all I know, but this may be a blessing for him and me. With a few deft strokes, I write the title.

Joxus and Company.

The boy watches me, eager to know my secrets. I watch him as I document my story. The words of an era that have passed unnoticed by these innocent brown eyes. I begin the first chapter of my life with the story of how I left my parents.

It's a great story, and you have a good start.  Keep it up :)

Well.  There are a few errors that I have found.  One huge one being the title, but some others are word usage issues and preferences that do not match up.

Here we go.

1.  Revise to:  "where I need to go.", "where to go to." or "what I need to improve in." etc.  "where to go" is fairly generic, and does not express the point you are trying to get across effectively.
2.  Remove comma.
3.  The scars, blisters and bruises are not taking action in the word "rampage."  This is a very active word, and implies more than being "out of control" or generically "agressive."  A good option might be "rage."
4.  Might be too much by including "another."
5.  Is the wall or the bench made of metal?  You need to rephrase this.
6.  This word doesn't quite express the kind of "busy and diligent"  It sounds as if the people were ordered and sorted in a specific way before they were put on a train.
7.  Revise to:  "it's"
8.  Don't invert this sentence; make it more straight-forward to make it easier for the reader to read: "I can feel his small, warm radiance as he [...]"
9.  Does this boy evoke pity on the narrator?  Do you mean "Compassionate" or "Innocent?"
10.  Could be rephrased.
11.  Cleché.  Plus, the eyes are witnesses of life, not the participant.
12.  Is this meant to be all on its own?
13.  You can make this easier to understand if the adverb is used to show more shyness than experimental social initiative.  Also, there appears to be no inference to his mother before, so why is it being introduced now as if the reader was already introduced to this character?  Never make the reader assume.
14.  The conjunction "and" does not tie the two parts of the sentences together because they are not alike.  Replace with "but."
15.  Is he skillfully responding?  Revise this.
16.  The following few lines say that he is "whipping out a small satchel."  Rephrase this.  "Whipping out" is an over-active verb for quickly developing and saying something.  Also the word "answer" in incorrect, because there was nothing to reply to, however, using the word "reply" for instance, indicates that the boy is trying to continue the conversation.
17.  You said that he "stared at [me] blankly" already.  You might want to revise this line.
18.  You don't need this fancy of a word here.  Use instead:  "offers", "hands", "gives", etc.
19.  You don't need this fancy of a word here.  Use instead:  "grabs", "grasps", etc.
20.  Use a hyphen for better effect.
21.  A metal hook does not own the attributes to be tired.  Use a different word or none at all.
22.  For best effect, rewrite the line to show contrast to the narrator's eyes through experience.
23.  Rephrase.

Yes, I know that I am quite picky when it comes to this stuff, but it's a lot easier to read once certain revisions are made from the points above.

It's a great story, and you have a good start.  Keep it up :)

Damn.  Correct MY story please?

On a side note, I doubt he'll take ANY of that advice looking at how he types and acts.

Damn.  Correct MY story please?

On a side note, I doubt he'll take ANY of that advice looking at how he types and acts.

Yeah he doesn't seem like the type.

I may just be imagining things and I apologise if that's the case but I believe the OP is not asking whether he is good at writing, because he clearly already has that confidence in his skill already and therefore did not come here for constructive criticism more than he did for compliments.

-snip-

You have a fine taste in writing you know. I would love it if you could critique my work sometime.

when I read the thread title I thought you meant handwriting
This.

and therefore did not come here for constructive criticism more than he did for compliments.

You have a fine taste in writing you know. I would love it if you could critique my work sometime.
1)  He said in the intro "where to go."  That's practically asking for constructive criticism.
2)  I'd be glad to :)

1)  He said in the intro "where to go."  That's practically asking for constructive criticism.
2)  I'd be glad to :)
Partly so my good friend. You took it that way and that's a way to go. I'm open to criticism all the time, since I'm quite lonely as a writer in my sector of real life.

In that aspect, I have a hard time cranking out a real story due to my own personal problems and the lack of help without actual people in my life who are interested and are acute with this kind of stuff.

New version, a bit softer and a lot simpler

_____________________________ _____________________________ _____________________________ _____________________________ __________________
The train glides into the station, a bird of prey ready to swallow the hapless creatures. Creatures of gray, drab, the rainbows of happiness diminished. I watch from my perch, a bench; waiting for my turn at redemption. Redemption for my wrongs that will never come to light again. I look inwards instead, those faces that have passed me by.

Fading memories, I smile to myself recounting them. Wars passed, the scars of them still lingering on and inside my body. Hollowed out furrows in the dry farms of my mind, waiting to be planted with next memories crop. I sit on the bench, its metal cool to the touch, the audible breeze of the AC whispering by.

The bench ties me to the mortal world, this world that has forgotten. I wait for the chance to seize these people from Death’s grasp and make them live for something. Something more than work, war, and the wrath of the world! But alas, they remain those drab people; and their children just beginning to become those burgeoning young gray people. Most are exactly how a lot of people were like in my day.

Happy about the world as it was. Curious how to change it for the better. Spry to the changing times. Resilient to the opposition. My generation fought for that so dearly, to be crushed by their own gains and anxiety. Would anyone say that I was sad, for all that I had seen and done? Would anyone care that I was one of that generation, willing to whittle my way to histories core?

But no, nobody does care any mind about me. The man with a black, stringy beard; purple skin and a cap almost torn to pieces. I cry a little inside this time, just go ahead I told myself, let those tears remind you of the hurt and the happiness you shared. I sing a bit to myself in my head, recounting those old songs from my time.

My mental train is stopped by a presence. A boy has just appeared on the bench with me, intently staring me down. That stare isn’t at all serious, more curious and foreboding than anything else. His eyes are brown. Brown like the coats that were popular amongst my old friends. Brown like the eyes of my loved and my passed loved ones.

Those eyes seem to melt people so easily, blue being the fierce color, brown being the heartwarming, and green being the intelligent kind. His eyes seemed to bore my own soul, and as they worked their way inside, he spoke. His voice was that gentle kind, yet seemingly a little deceiving.

“Mister,” he said in a heavy British accent, “what’re you doing here?”

I looked at him with a sort of dazed look, him returning the same. My answer remained at bay, I waited for his recognition. Next he spoke with a light Boston accent. I was surprised at his adept tongue.

“So, yah not a talka aren’t you? You have some guts to sit heya,” he launched, leaning in a bit comically toward me, “ the police got ya hobos on the run!”

I gazed at him a bit deeper, concentrating on him. I felt him shaking as I placed my gloved hand on him. He shook so violently to me, radiating an intensity unlike I’d seen in awhile. This time, he spoke normally; at least to me.

“You seem like a man that’s seen a lot. I assume thats true,” he sighed a bit and turned his gaze away, “My grandfather recently passed on. He used to say that his inspiration for his life in aviation was this one man.”

He looked down at the ground, wringing his hands. He paused for that long and I stared into the back of his head. I wanted him to answer that lingering question, who was that man? He sat there for a bit longer, his breath casting the occasional cloud in the frosty air. I begged him to go on, pleaded him even, just with my eyes. He never replied, rather just sat there for a while longer.

I understood how he felt, one of the shining achievers in his life now gone like that match blown away. He didn’t continue, and I watched him silently cry to himself. I remember how I used to do the exact same thing, more times than once. After sobs shone through his next words.

“The man,” he said, mopping up the choked tears, “he used to say, was a hard chip on the outside but a soft cotton candy loving hippie on the inside.” At the next few words, he choked down the rest of his painful meal, and continued with a little bit more confidence, “He would laugh as he recounted the jokes and the loveual innuendos that the guy used, a practical jokester one moment and a general the next. He wondered what had happened to him after The Reform.”

That was when I knew who he was talking about, and I said softly so that he could only hear. My voice surprised me as I formed the words, a raspy, soothing, baritone.

“You know kid,” I said, “ you may be closer to that man than you thought. Your grandfather seems to be the kind of man to know that. What was his favorite color?”

“Navy, or was it Army Olive? He always was interested in the military.”

“What’s your name sonny?”

“Jenxas Gynus the Second, after my father Geenus Gynus and after his father, my grandfather, InGenius Gynus.” he belted out like a great title.

“You may have found your grandfathers man. Or maybe just a person who’s seen a lot of what your grandfather has seen.”

“You really think?” he said, his voice responding to the amazement in his eyes, “he could be in that crowd or on that train, headed off to escape the public eye for another day?”

“Or he could be closer.”

“Like?” he asked, “Where could a guy hide other than the crowd and the...”

He stopped, looked at me, looked at my face, squinted a bit, then a flash of recognition hit him.

“What type of bumbling idiot am I? You’re the guy he was talking about!” he breathed heavy, an accented exhilaration, “A guy called Joxus, ‘the most magical,wonderful,crazy man in the world’!”

“If you say so,”I said pulling down my scarf, “I can be that man.”

He began to pelt me with questions, a majority about the war and before The Reform. He stopped to collect himself, as did I, ready for the next batch of questions. He looked at me with a little bit of confusion, probably beckoning for a little return. So I did, I opened my doors a little wider.

“Do you want to know a story from my eyes?” I asked softly. This was the time, I felt it.

“From the famous Joxus! Why not?” he exclaimed. He bounced a bit, excitedly. “I can stay,” he said, calming down a bit, “but I obviously won’t give you any heart attacks after your life story!”

So I launched into a story. I would write it down and name it later, for it was my memoriam to my life.

Joxus and Company
« Last Edit: September 11, 2012, 07:46:31 PM by ImperealOfficer »