Okay, so there are two girls that like me/I like. The first one dyes her hair a lot and likes MLP:FiM, we've both been friends for around 4 years and have started liking each other lately. The other girl is raised strictly and has sensitive Christian parents, (she is not allowed to celebrate Halloween, watch certain cartoons, etc.) We never really talked to each other that much but I can tell she likes me. Who should I pick?