Supreme Court: "forget the right to remain silent" (not literally)

[Muslim]

So the Supreme Court said you must speak to remain the right to remain silent now

http://www.ibtimes.com/supreme-court-self-incrimination-ruling-no-right-remain-silent-unless-you-speak-1324515

[Ad Bot]

[Night Fox]

I don't see anything wrong with that tbh
body language is just as meaningful as words are

[Harm94]

Do you even 5th amendment supreme court? What's next they? Do they get rid of due process.

[Katadeus]

I don't see anything wrong with that tbh
body language is just as meaningful as words are

If they simply went with this it would have been much better.
They did the right thing in the wrong way

[Nonnel]

how the forget can they decide someone's guilty because they were shuffling their feet

[Night Fox]

how the forget can they decide someone's guilty because they were shuffling their feet

body language is just as meaningful as words are

[Tomcat]

cop: okay so he has a nervous look in the interrogation room, better put that down on the transcript...

*nervous look*
THERE, JUST AS GOOD AS A CONFESSION!

[Nonnel]

That's complete bullstuff

If he was giving them the middle finger every time they ask a question, I can see why they would decide he was guilty
but they didn't have anything. No. forget that. forget them.

[Night Fox]

cop: okay so he has a nervous look in the interrogation room, better put that down on the transcript...
*nervous look*
THERE, JUST AS GOOD AS A CONFESSION!

more like cop: did you kill this man?
suspect: *adjusts collar and looks around nervously*
cop: *thinks: "that's just evidence, which can and should be used in court"*

nowhere was it even implied that it was what incriminated him

[Harm94]

I'm not much of a conspiracy theorist here, but the it seems like the government is trying to eliminate the bill of rights and the constitution. 1st amendment(SOPA), 2nd Amendment, 4th Amendment(Patriot ACT, NDAA), 13th Amendment(schools requiring kids perform community service in order to graduate).

[Nonnel]

I'm not much of a conspiracy theorist here, but the it seems like the government is trying to eliminate the bill of rights. 1st amendment(SOPA), 2nd Amendment, 4th Amendment(Patriot ACT, NDAA).

Yep. The government wants to control us and eliminate all our rights so it can have complete power.

[Tomcat]

more like cop: did you kill this man?
suspect: *adjusts collar and looks around nervously*
cop: *thinks: "that's just evidence, which can and should be used in court"*

nowhere was it even implied that it was what incriminated him

who isn't going to be nervous when someone loving asks you if you killed someone?

secondly, that is circumstantial evidence if it can be considered evidence at all.
 

[Night Fox]

who isn't going to be nervous when someone loving asks you if you killed someone?

if you didn't do it, why would you be nervous? there's an amount of anxiety you'll feel because of being in the interrogation room, but you can just say "no." talk about it with your lawyer, and if needed, he or she will definitely mention the expected effects of being in an interrogation room

[Pecon]

I'd be pretty nervous just talking to a police officer.

[Night Fox]

I'd be pretty nervous just talking to a police officer.

why?