Author Topic: Study Room  (Read 2847 times)

The screen on the left is based off this right?
http://www.leetlegacy.tk/homepage.html

It's actually my desktop longer ago. And that page is made after my desktop. And I made that page. And I made my desktop. And I made this. And this made my desktop.
For more details consult page 67.

Maybe I just don't like the style but this isn't more than a 5-6/10 for me.

It just seems cluttered, little to no attention payed to wall trimmings or ceiling or floor, it just seems thrown together. Style is inconsistent. Seems very cramped and the ceiling is very low.

Thanks for the actual feedback except the part where you made me has a sad with that really low score :(.
  • Indeed no attention at all given to ceiling, as I said previously I'll keep that in mind next time.
  • Wall trimmings are understandable, I wanted to try out that glass style on the wall on the middle-left.
  • What else could've made the floor better?; Besides the parquet pattern, I attempted to add a little more to it by adding a different pattern in the +-middle of the cubicle-like thing.
  • Cluttered?; What if that's the point; I did not make a new room, I made a room to be lived in; I could've made just the desk, the cabinets and the sofa; Let's say keep the bookcase too; But then it would've been too empty wouldn't it?; It bases more on space-usage than being empty, pretty much what you'd expect from an actual room/house; You wouldn't just have a big room with 4-5 items would you?
  • Ceiling very low understandable, though having it 7 bricks high which is consistent in all my builds, I'll attempt a higher ceiling next time.
  • Regarding style inconsistency, that's not really as intentional as plausible, mainly in the terms of not everything suddenly being bought from the same store; If I had 3 different couches that would be stupid; But if I have a couch, a cabinet and a desk with inconsistent style it's not necessary to be the same style; Perhaps given, the same color (to reach that same style), but even the misleading color might be intentional to create diversity, wouldn't it?

Almost realistic room, decently 10\10

honestly i don't think a boring ceiling is an issue because clearly this isn't a study in some upscale mansion. Instead it's more like a repurposed oddly-shaped room in some common home. The same goes for the walls.

And in addition making things look cluttered but neat is really difficult to pull off. nice job.
only thing i don't like to much is the distance between the desktop box and the monitors/keyboard/mouse but i guess with long cables its alright.

only thing i don't like to much is the distance between the desktop box and the monitors/keyboard/mouse but i guess with long cables its alright.

I'll remember to check for that next time, I just realized it looks really weird and I agree.
By the way, did no one see the easter egg at the door glass at the day picture?



6-7/10

Too many props, it looks like you got lazy with the detail and used props as a way of backup, I'm imaging it without the props and with brickbuilt bricks and I think that looks much more authentic.

It's a nice room and all, an okay size, although I have no idea what more there is apart from this one room, but it does look like you tried to cram everything into one spot, which makes it look cluttered, not messy but just like it has a lot of unnecessary items that might be taking the spotlight out from what you are actually trying to point out.

hoh stuff u guys nuts?

10/10

There's too much going on 4/10

Regarding everyone who says things are cluttered, those are the first three images of searching "room" on Google. And worth mentioning that those images are most likely not meant to be realistic, but more likely meant for marketing.



So, really, what exactly are you bloody thinking of? You can't tell me your room consists of your desk, your PC and your bed. Eventually a dresser.
Those rooms are about as cluttered as this is as whole. If you are counting that this room is not made for marketing, and instead going for realism, of course you'd have things going on. I am looking at my desk in real life and it has more items than furniture items on the build. And that's not counting what's on my dresser/bed/the side of the desk/my furniture/on my table.