Mafia - The forum game! Let the post-game brown townysis commence!

[Cuddles le Bear]

There's no such thing as a stalemate. The first person to reach 50% is lynched, i.e. TR.

Ah.
I forgot.

[Ad Bot]

[The Resonte!]

i give up i was mafia all along

forgive me

as you lay dead, please

forgive me

i forgive you
at least bury me with flowers
or around the noose

[CharlesSpeaking]

i forgive you
at least bury me with flowers
or around the noose

who should i kill to win

[[]----[]]

Two days.  Two murders.  Two lynchings.

But now it's over.

The Resonte! was lynched.  He was the Mafia.

GAME OVER!
THE INNOCENTS HAVE WON!

Players:
Cybertails1998 - Innocent, died Night 2
CharlesSpeaking - Cop
childofdarkness016 - Innocent
The Resonte! - Mafia, died Day 2
Gojira - Mafia, died Day 1
Cuddles le Bear - Innocent
Kingdaro - Doctor, died Night 1

This was an interesting game!  I have a lot of stuff to say about it, which I'll post soon in a post-game brown townysis.  In the meantime, I'd like to hear what you thought, particularly about the game, how it was run, and possible changes to the rules!

[The Resonte!]

who should i kill to win

yourself


nooooooooooooo

[The Resonte!]

DAMNIT CHILD IF ONLY YOU SWITCHED YOUR VOTE TO CHARLES

THEN
I WOULD RISE

[Kingdaro]

In response to being killed night 1,

[CharlesSpeaking]

all survivors have names beginning with C

despite using no logic at all in this game, it was much more thrilling than mafia madness

it was truly a moment to remember, it was mafia

also, not sure about the idea of PMing being allowed, though i'm not experienced in MM

can't maf just discuss plans

[childofdarkness016]

Again, daytime should be first so everyone gets a chance to play. We should also consider adding 2 or 3 new roles, in addition to expanding the player slots to 16 (3 Mafia, 1 Cop, 1 Doctor, 3 New Roles, 8 Innocents) or 12 (3 Mafia, 1 Cop, 1 Doctor, 2 New Roles, everyone else Innocent).

[blazerblock2]

all survivors have names beginning with C

conspiracy

[Kingdaro]

I'd also like to add that I don't really like the hammering rule, as it doesn't give very much time for people to change their mind and unvote/revote.

also, not sure about the idea of PMing being allowed, though i'm not experienced in MM

can't maf just discuss plans

May as well allow it; it's not like you can prevent it.

[CharlesSpeaking]

I'd also like to add that I don't really like the hammering rule, as it doesn't give very much time for people to change their mind and unvote/revote.

that's why in forum mafia, you be careful with your votes

[childofdarkness016]

DAMNIT CHILD IF ONLY YOU SWITCHED YOUR VOTE TO CHARLES

THEN
I WOULD RISE

You accused me of being in the Mafia when it was rather blatant that you were a mafioso.

Also, if I may bring up my two ideas for roles...


Attorney
He chooses one person to save during a lynching. While normally, his power can only be used at night, he is allowed to use his skills ONCE per game during the day. Think of him as a reverse doctor.

Medium
She can commune with dead bodies, revealing their killer. To solve balance issues, this is determined by a coin flip. If it fails, the Medium gets no information.

Also, I just noticed that these roles correspond with Maya and Phoenix from Ace Attorney. Happy coincidences.

I'd also like to add that I don't really like the hammering rule, as it doesn't give very much time for people to change their mind and unvote/revote.
May as well allow it; it's not like you can prevent it.

PMing people is fun and adds to the challenge of the game! I PMed several innocents, hoping to get some information, which, sadly failed. :C. Still, it could be useful for Mafias to deceive people and whatnot.

[The Resonte!]

You accused me of being in the Mafia when it was rather blatant that you were a mafioso.

no i didn't :C

there's actually tons and tons of classes, like Millers (duh)
blacksmith (gives vests every night to people, which protects them against 1 bullet shot)

you can try to add abductor, where the guy just disappears in the middle
of the day, not allowed to post,
and no "death" sequence is found until the next day or so.

there's also a hooker. (roleblocks someone, maybe once game or night. makes it so doctors don't doc and
cops don't make reports.)

[childofdarkness016]

no i didn't :C

there's actually tons and tons of classes, like Millers (duh)
blacksmith (gives vests every night to people, which protects them against 1 bullet shot)

you can try to add abductor, where the guy just disappears in the middle
of the day, not allowed to post,
and no "death" sequence is found until the next day or so.

there's also a hooker. (roleblocks someone, maybe once game or night. makes it so doctors don't doc and
cops don't make reports.)

I know, but I think Brackets wants to add roles that players suggest. At least I somehow got that implication.

And, please, you were getting defensive when I accused your teammate. :S