go with the 17 year. it'll give you a much sharper taste, and it'll couple better with foods. if you're of age (didn't bother to check your sig), i recommend making a charcuterie plate with some fresh proscuitto, crackers, cheese, and some crisp white wine like a pinot grigio. it'll all compliment itself really well.
or if you're going for bonus points, get some craisens