Poll

Does media violence have an impact on aggression in children?

Yes
No
Other (Post)

Author Topic: The effect of media violence on children  (Read 2260 times)

Pretty much depends on the person. Most people don't relate video games with real-life experiences, so most people probably aren't affected that way by it. If, for example, the same violence was happening in front of them, I highly doubt they'd view it in the same light as a game. Now, for someone who does relate video games more closely with real life and has a harder time differentiating between them, well, unless they're already some violent person, I'd have to imagine they'd actually just avoid violent games/media even more than your average person - it would seem a bit too "real" to them. So, while I think it can have some very minor effects, unless the person is seriously messed up in the head, I don't think violent media leads to violence IRL. Some unneeded agression and frustration, maybe. But not really violence.

Depends on the age.
Very young children will imitate what they see. If they see violence, they'll imitate that violence, and I would interpret this study as evidence of that.

But as long as parents don't allow children to play/watch things WAY out of their age range, there's no problem

I'll basically be talking from anecdotal evidence and a general reckoning on the subject, so take it all with a pinch of salt.

For the most part I don't believe that media violence as a whole (particularly video games which take the brunt of the blame) is responsible for creating violent children.
I won't deny that it can desensitise children to violence, but that doesn't necessitate children imitating such violence.

I don't know the statistics for such cases (particularly because records don't go back so far) but I'm pretty sure there was equal, if not more cases of violent children prior to media violence becoming prevalent (I'm talking pre-TV, pre-film, pre-Radio).
I would say that there probably was more violence in children in this age, and that the cause of it was poverty, poor parenting (should it even exist as orphans were much more common due to social/medical reasons).


There's no doubt that a child who has access to violent media (whether games, newspapers, TV programmes, etc...) may be inspired by the depictions in that media, but that's no different than hearing of violent acts in books or poetry or in general discussion.
Bouncing off of Headcrab Zombie's post young children exposed to such things may be more inclined to imitate out of innocence, but that imitation could be of anything.

I think that there has to be a predisposition towards violence in a child, whether a result of mental instability, psychological trauma, or simply a case of a complete lack of violence. Blaming violence in the media is clutching at straws for a reason when you simply don't want to blame someone responsible, whether it's the child, the parent or the state.

I use to play Sim City a lot. Now I'm currently the mayor of my town.

It can have influence on people with mental issues, yes, but I wouldn't say it causes healthy people to become violent necesarrily.

Regardless, its loving stupid to put limits on them just because a couple kids were partially influenced by them to do stupid violent acts

videos games do not cause anger and violence problems
they can fuel existing ones though
« Last Edit: August 10, 2014, 10:51:23 AM by Nomel »

What if it's the opposite? What if children are having an effect on media violence? Just something to think about...
it does iirc
ive seen if from a few different sources but yeah its bc we understand like, the expense of human life or smth by comparing the disposable lives of virtual people vs actual lives that can't be brought back ever

i just realized i read your comment wrong but
yeah it actually

As someone who has fired a few guns on the range, I can tell you the real life equivalent is pretty scary considering you are actually holding a easily lethal tool.


Depends on the person. Some people are easily impressioned by violent games and other media. Others however know that what they are messing with it not how to act.

Gotta agree with dooble, violence in media can desensitize, but I don't think it creates violence children.

Parents are responsible for children, how they do their job and some genetic dispositions is all that matters.

no and i am positive that you are not the original owner of that avatar unless you are an alt

DiceyGrammar = Boltster.

This has been known for quite a while.



Yes and no, in my opinion. It's not going to affect a relatively mentally stable child, but a child who may have such issues may be more prone to being affected by violent media.

Yes and no, in my opinion. It's not going to affect a relatively mentally stable child, but a child who may have such issues may be more prone to being affected by violent media.
Its not going to effect a mentally unstable child either. Stable or not it may or may not effect you. It depends on how your brought up along side it. If all you see is violence than you're probably going to think thats right, if you grew up playing it but seen that the world is not a bunch of people beating each other with bats and hijacking every car they see than they'll most likely think "Oh, this is a game and not how I should base life"

I'm inclined to say no when it comes to mentally stable people, but not everyone is mentally stable.