Author Topic: Is it possible to look into the past, using mirrors?  (Read 3229 times)

If there was a giant mirror one light-year away, it would be a grand total of 2 years for the light to make it to it and then come back, correct?
Yes. But it would take one year for the light to get to earth, meaning you won't even be able to see the mirror for a whole year.

so if we got a mirror to orbit around earth at light speed, would we be able to see the future  :cookieMonster:

so if we got a mirror to orbit around earth at light speed, would we be able to see the future  :cookieMonster:
wut

wut

i don't know; it doesn't make sense but it seemed relevant

If there was a giant mirror one light-year away, it would be a grand total of 2 years for the light to make it to it and then come back, correct?
I don't think so. Think of it like boom the mirror appeared, then light is being traveled to the mirror, from earth, at the same time, light from the mirror is being traveled to earth. So you'll be seeing the the mirror display 1 year ago I believe.

miracles all up in this bitch

so if we got a mirror to orbit around earth at light speed, would we be able to see the future  :cookieMonster:
If a mirror orbited the earth at light speed, certain parts of the earth would sometimes have rapid flashes of light because of reflections from the sun.

That's it.

I don't think so. Think of it like boom the mirror appeared, then light is being traveled to the mirror, from earth, at the same time, light from the mirror is being traveled to earth. So you'll be seeing the the mirror display 1 year ago I believe.
That doesn't make sense at all. If there was suddenly a mirror 1 light year away, then the light would have to travel from earth all the way to the mirror (which would take one year) and then travel all the way back to earth from the mirror (which would take another year).

So you would see two years into the past.



Think of it like this. If the mirror is x lightyears away from earth, then it would take light y years to make the round-trip to the mirror and back.

Distance is x and the time it takes is y. X is doubled, because not only does the light have to reach the mirror, but it also has to travel all the way back to earth.

y = 2x

So if the mirror was two light years away instead of one, then you could look back four years into the past.

y = 2(2)
y = 4
« Last Edit: October 23, 2014, 12:15:26 PM by blueblur121 »

So we should put it half a light year away!

Also wouldn't there be a problem with getting the telescope to face the mirror since we keep rotating?

You would see 2 years you're right. You're technically seeing the mirror a year away, whats in the mirror is another year away so yeah two. stuff man

So we should put it half a light year away!
Also wouldn't there be a problem with getting the telescope to face the mirror since we keep rotating?
Yeah but getting the mirror a light year away is no prob


that would be some giant ass mirror

that would be some giant ass mirror
And it would need to be unbelieveably perfectly flat, even microscopic bumps would cause catastrophic distortions at half a light years distance.

thank you based microsoft paint

in one of the books in this series he mentioned that their alien civilization or whatever had a little system like this, so they could see what happened at some point before, I guess for investigations and stuff like that
Also wouldn't there be a problem with getting the telescope to face the mirror since we keep rotating?
why would it be any different than looking at some other celestial object

but we wouldn't looking into the past. We'd be looking at a recording.