Author Topic: Could the steam workshop replace RTB?  (Read 1490 times)

sorry if this has been answered/asked and i haven't seen it yet, but i was wondering if the steam workshop would replace RTB with it's addon manager system like Gmod - maybe even a duplication system if it was made default? or is there something terribly wrong with all of this that i don't know about

As far as i've heard, Steam Workshop for anything sucks. Can't verify first hand so take this with a grain of salt.

As far as i've heard, Steam Workshop for anything sucks. Can't verify first hand so take this with a grain of salt.

the hell you heard that because it's actually really good imo. i haven't heard anyone complain about it unless you count people poking at the obsession of big animey tiddies in the skyrim mod community

the hell you heard that because it's actually really good imo. i haven't heard anyone complain about it unless you count people poking at the obsession of big animey tiddies in the skyrim mod community
While I've only taken quick glances at other workshops, I've seen some that are just an unorganized mess, such as the L4D2 workshop. It even seems like whoever(Steam I guess?) manages the workshop section of steam doesn't even bother to actually fix anything, at best "blocking" what they consider inappropriate content.

I'd much rather prefer not using the workshop from what I can tell of its management.


It has no form of community approval. Malicious/backdoored addons will get downloaded, wreak havok, and delete any trace of their actions before you can even realize what's going on.

It has no form of community approval. Malicious/backdoored addons will get downloaded, wreak havok, and delete any trace of their actions before you can even realize what's going on.
on second thought
yeah, the community can't be trusted with this lol

on second thought
yeah, the community can't be trusted with this lol
^

We have the forums, and its moderated.


would require some major QA but it would be awesome if it could be done
RTB was nice because it was specifically targeted tho

It has no form of community approval. Malicious/backdoored addons will get downloaded, wreak havok, and delete any trace of their actions before you can even realize what's going on.
isnt valve stingy as forget about malicious content tho

isnt valve stingy as forget about malicious content tho
The BLHack DLL was posted on a steam guide for blockland. It was reported by multiple people multiple times, and it was still up for weeks until the guy who made it took it down himself.

By the time it gets taken down the damage is already done, when it can all be completely prevented through a thorough review process.
« Last Edit: December 04, 2014, 07:19:43 PM by Ipquarx »

So then Badspot should get a couple people to review submissions like Ephialtes did. Not hard to figure out.

From my steam workshop experience it's okay I guess.  Mostly depends on the game.
Prison Architect overlaps.  Skyrim load orders cause so many crashes.  Gmod is the worse,causing all these script errors and updates that don't update anything,I have a minute of lag before I can click on anything on the main menu.  TF2 one weapons are VERY RARELY accepted.  Plague Inc. works quite good.  Goat simulator has crashes (I couldn't use Shrek goat,it would only crash).  Also on the Gmod workshop I saw a nude ragdoll and it was up for a couple days before taken down.

I'd rather have the old RTB as my mod manager or the ingame one.

EDIT: What about all those love dupes in Gmod? Those are never taken down but nude ragdolls are.
« Last Edit: December 05, 2014, 08:16:47 PM by randomtroll39 »

Workshop is loving terrible, anybody who is telling you its good is probably loving lying, my entire experience with it and gmod is absolutely horrible.

The subscription system us bad, just bad. Addons fail to download most of the time and then there is the damn file restrictions.
There is size restrictions too, and those are an even bigger pain in the ass.

What's the worst part? If the owner of the addon, deletes their addons, they also get deleted from your folders! Everyone would completely like to have a favorite addon wiped from existence because the creator had a hissy fit and pulled them all off the workshop. Bullstuff, replace subscription with Download and everything would be better.

And now let me get started on how well organized the damn thing is...its not! Its a giant cluster forget of dis-organized stuff.
There is no category system that works properly, even the filters break all the time, and then there's the search function.... boy oh boy how could they have messed up a basic search function? By having it break all the time like the filters, and sometimes searching only by the most specific type of keyword.

TLDR;Its an absurd mess that nobody should use, if anything they should recycle the workshop into something that lets you just download instead of the god awful subscription system.