This isn't some cut n' dry thing for a lot of people. I really think you should put a "I'm not sure" option in the poll.
I'm definitely a Deist, which means I believe that there is some form of higher being, but it doesn't coincide with modern religion, which I believe in general to be mostly hoax-y. I could go on about explaining this and whatnot but basically my belief is I have no loving idea if there's an afterlife but I sure as hell hope that I still get to do stuff after I die, like, even if I just get reborn into another person or a different intelligent species with no recollection of my previous life. I think anything besides going away forever would be ideal for me, because I absolutely hate the idea of going away forever. I do however particularly like the idea of extraordinarily bad people going to a place where they get tortured for infinity. I'm not talking your average petty thief here, I'm talking like serial rapists, child molesters, Flash Mobers, stuff like that. Perhaps I'm somewhat of a bad person for that? I have no idea.
Either way, hey, OP, put an "I don't know" option into the poll.