Yeah neither would I, those are literally the only options, either he did it or he didn't
Yeah mostly obviously with the way Pie has been acting in these threads that he could just be lying again,
but with the kind of person Pie is, you'd expect him to forget a dog. I mean I'm pretty sure he's admitted to being a Zoophile before. That's why I'm more in the neutral here, but I'm really leaning to the lying side of things.