how about like a hockey mask or somin lol?
Donator rewards are a tricky subject because if you want the rewards to be an incentive alone to donate, then they have to be useful or cool. You obviously can't just throw in powerful weapons because that would alienate everyone without access to the weaponry, but vanity items alone aren't usually an incentive to donate.
Most people donate for the benefits or to help the server because they like the server.
That's not a "reward", that's a purchase.
Was this a necessary distinction?