when you pit SU against creepypastas i can see where there's debate but i'd put creepypastas simply because they have a larger margin for being.... eugh
i can see where SU comes from tho. like it's honestly not bad compared to FNaF, homestuck, SWL, ect. but now bc of the keystone motel incident..... yeah..... let's hope that we can avoid it, tho