best cookie

[Squideey]

time for the most serious decision of your life.

choose. oh jesus I hope this thread shouldn't actually be in forum games

[Ad Bot]

[Sentry]

Peanut Butter

[Foxscotch]

man it's a good thing I can choose three cus that was easy
chocolate chip, peanut butter, and sugar

[Defendor]

ones with m&m's in them

[Squideey]

ones with m&m's in them

m&m cookies are just gay chocolate chip cookies

[Tetris]

m&m cookies are just gay chocolate chip cookies

this is a no cookie shaming environment

[TheBlackParrot]

oatmeal raisin

[Masterlegodude]

Chocolate chip and sugar cookies are my favorites

[Yosher]

chocolate chip is the good stuff

[foulprairiedog]

shortbread is the best because the goodness is spread all around the cookie instead of being condensed into chocolate chips

[Yosher]

shortbread is the best because the goodness is spread all around the cookie instead of being condensed into chocolate chips

very good point

[Teneksi]

But the non-chocolate part of the chocolate chip cookie is sweet enough to be good on its own, but then you get bonus chocolate. And it doesn't work to just eat chocolate, 'cause that isn't a cookie.


I chose chocolate chip, peanut butter, and oatmeal, as when all three are combined, they form:



the monster cookie.

undeniably the best.

[Defendor]

shortbread is the best because the goodness is spread all around the cookie instead of being condensed into chocolate chips

a smart quantity tactic but i still don't like it's taste

if they somehow spread out the goodness of m&m's all around the cookie however......

[pch]

chocolate chip + sugar + snickerdoodle for sure

[Camel]

if you ain't votin macaroon you aint' votin