This belongs in Help.
Sorry I didn't know
Are you clicking Query LAN? Because the master server is listing the public IP.
I'm querying internet but for some reason the Dedicated Server is returning the private IP. My computer is not on the same subnet as the server so it won't LAN either way.
EDIT: It appears to be an issue with my reverse NAT translation setup. Fixed.
Having re-read it, it is not the private IP it is connecting to. It is connecting to a public IP but not my server's public IP, a different public IP.