Poll

what

Clones (phase 1)
4 (8.9%)
Clones (phase 2)
8 (17.8%)
All clones
1 (2.2%)
Stormtrooper (empire)
19 (42.2%)
Stormtrooper (first order)
5 (11.1%)
all stormtroopers
8 (17.8%)

Total Members Voted: 45

Author Topic: Clones or Stormtroopers  (Read 4502 times)

stormtroopers because they're named after cool military positions and clones are a byproduct of the prequels, and if you like the prequels, history shows you're the cancer killing society
the prequels were stuff but the concept of the clones and all the stuff that went down in the clone wars makes them awesome

the problem with the clones is that everyone involved with writing the clones dropped the ball on the full implication of having a clone army, so it's just awkward as forget

I much prefer a straight up army to that

yeah i've always wondered whats the point of having a bunch of clones when you can use robots. cool nonetheless.

stormtroopers because they're named after cool military positions and clones are a byproduct of the prequels, and if you like the prequels, history shows you're the cancer killing society
the clones were pretty much the coolest part of the prequels though. phase 2 armor is literally the coolest stuff.

the problem with the clones is that everyone involved with writing the clones dropped the ball on the full implication of having a clone army, so it's just awkward as forget

I much prefer a straight up army to that
star wars is chock full of cool ideas and concepts that lucas never touched on. a clone army is morally forgeted up, but everyone just kinda goes with it. what happens when these thinking, feeling humans want rights? shooty boy #23456789 wants to be a chef, not a soldier.

yeah i've always wondered whats the point of having a bunch of clones when you can use robots. cool nonetheless.
The clone army was secretly paid for by the Emperor and wasn't known about until like days before the Battle of Geonosis. So when the Jedi get overrun by the droids and the Geonosians, they got loving desperate knowing they had an army at their disposal right then and there.
« Last Edit: November 07, 2016, 08:27:20 PM by Cowboy Dude »

fun fact there are people out there who think all stormtroopers are clones

dont let your kids watch the prequels

The clone army was secretly paid for by the Emperor and wasn't known about until like days before the Battle of Geonosis. So when the Jedi get overrun by the droids and the Geonosians, they got loving desperate knowing they had an army at their disposal right then and there.
yeah i think everyone who knows star wars knows that the clone wars was just made up to kill the jedi

I personally think that all time from the clone wars (the end of attack of the clones) onward is like the cool stuff of star wars. Literally 85% of the canon star wars universe (that isnt in novel form) takes place during the clone wars and the jedi purge

i think its only cool because in the clone wars the good guys have a whole army and stuff and it feels like halo, but in the empire stuff the good guys are a ragtag rebel force. it doesnt feel as good
« Last Edit: November 07, 2016, 08:30:24 PM by Perry »

You guys should read the X-wing series. Isn't canon anymore but it's got X-wings and Wedge Antilles.


the clones essentially wiped the jedi off the face of the deep core. the stormtroopers have yet to kill a jedi
How are they supposed to wipe out the jedi if the clones did it first? Clones only missed about 4.

Let's break it down

Stormtroopers
- Can barely see out of the helmet (which also looks ugly)
- Don't warn you to watch those wrist rockets
- Boring
+ Dark troopers are cool as hell (cyborg war vets with jumppacks and lighting guns)
+ Name is cooler
+ Not as lame as everyone thinks
+ Classic

Clones
- From the prequels
- Phase I armor was uncomfortable and obtrusive
- Backstory really doesn't make much sense (and ruined Boba Fett's original origin story)
+ Warn you to watch those wrist rockets
+ Were BAMFs in the old Clone Wars TV show (here is a Skillet AMV proving my point)
+ Colorful and varied (seriously. like dang dude, look at all these dudes. there are jousting clones)
+ Republic Commando. Enough said

You guys should read the X-wing series. Isn't canon anymore but it's got X-wings and Wedge Antilles.


Yub yub, commander. I love those books. Probably my favorite Star Wars series beside Republic Commando or the Thawn trilogy.
« Last Edit: November 08, 2016, 12:33:03 AM by Alteration »

Stormtrooper (imperial) of course

and this is why I'm addicted to Star Wars Battlefront II.

Every time I will play, it's always as a clone, wither it's a stormtrooper, or a clone from the prequels/clone wars era.

am i the only one who likes the first order ones the best

first order ones are badass but look derpy in 2d image like in the poll

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HA2ACgGWkco
I've watched this video and it's actually pretty interesting.
It talks about the history Clone Troopers and Stormtroopers and who would win in a fight against eachother.